May 06, 2010 <Back to Index>
|
Maximilien François Marie Isidore de Robespierre (6 May 1758 – 28 July 1794) is one of the best-known and most influential figures of the French Revolution. He largely dominated the Committee of Public Safety and was instrumental in the period of the Revolution commonly known as the Reign of Terror, which ended with his arrest and execution in 1794. Robespierre was influenced by 18th century Enlightenment philosophers such as Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Montesquieu, and he was a capable articulator of the beliefs of the left-wing bourgeoisie.
He was described as physically unimposing and immaculate in attire and
personal manners. His supporters called him "The Incorruptible", while
his adversaries called him the "Tyrant" and dictateur sanguinaire (bloodthirsty dictator). Maximilien de Robespierre was born in Arras, France. His family has been traced back to the 12th century in Picardy, Northern France; some of his direct ancestors in the male line were notaries in the little village of Carvin near Arras from the beginning of the 17th century. He is sometimes rumoured to have been of Irish descent, and it has been suggested that his surname could be a corruption of 'Robert Speirs'. His
paternal grandfather, Maximilien de Robespierre, established himself in
Arras as a lawyer. His father, Maximilien Barthélémy
François de Robespierre, also a lawyer at the Conseil d'Artois, married Jacqueline Marguerite Carrault, the daughter of a brewer, in 1758. Maximilien was the oldest of four children and was conceived out of wedlock - his siblings were Charlotte, Henriette and Augustin. To
hide the fact as best they could, his father and mother had a rushed
wedding (which the grandfather refused to attend). In 1764, Madame de
Robespierre died in childbirth. Her husband left Arras and wandered around Europe until his death in Munich in 1777, leaving the children to be brought up by their maternal grandfather and aunts. Maximilien attended the collège (middle school) of Arras when he was eight years old, already knowing how to read and write. In October of 1769, on the recommendation of the bishop, he obtained a scholarship at the Lycée Louis-le-Grand in Paris. Here he learned to admire the idealised Roman Republic and the rhetoric of Cicero, Cato and other classic figures. His fellow pupils included Camille Desmoulins and Stanislas Fréron. He also was exposed to Rousseau during
this time and adopted many of the same principles. Robespierre became
more intrigued by the idea of a virtuous self, a man who stands alone
accompanied only by his conscience. Shortly after his coronation, Louis XVI visited Louis-le-Grand.
Robespierre, then 17 years old, had been chosen out of five hundred
pupils to deliver a speech to welcome the king; as a prize-winning
student, the choice had been clear. On the day of speech, Robespierre
and the crowd waited for the king and queen for several hours in the
rain. Upon arrival, the royal couple remained in their coach for the
ceremony and immediately left thereafter. Robespierre would become one of those who eventually sought the death of the king. As
an adult, and possibly even as a young man, the greatest influence on
Robespierre's political ideas was Jean Jacques Rousseau. Robespierre’s
conception of revolutionary virtue and his program for constructing
political sovereignty out of direct participatory democracy came from
Rousseau, and in pursuit of these ideals he eventually became known
during the Jacobin Republic as “the Incorruptible.” Robespierre
believed that the people of France were fundamentally good and
therefore the people needed only to speak in order to advance the well
being of the nation. After having completed his law studies, Robespierre was admitted to the Arras bar. The Bishop of Arras, Louis François Marc Hilaire de Conzié, appointed him criminal judge in the Diocese of Arras in
March 1782. This appointment, which he soon resigned to avoid
pronouncing a sentence of death, did not prevent his practicing at the
bar. He quickly became a successful advocate and chose in principle to
represent the poor. During court hearings he was known to often
advocate the ideals of the Enlightenment and argue for the rights of
man: i.e. his clients. Later
in his career he read widely and also became interested in society in
general and became regarded as one of the best writers and most popular
young men of Arras. In
December 1783, he was elected a member of the academy of Arras, the
meetings of which he attended regularly. In 1784, he obtained a medal
from the academy of Metz for his essay on the question of whether the relatives of a condemned criminal should share his disgrace. He and Pierre Louis de Lacretelle,
an advocate and journalist in Paris, divided the prize. Many of his
subsequent essays were less successful, but Robespierre was compensated
for these failures by his popularity in the literary and musical
society at Arras, known as the "Rosatia", of which Lazare Carnot, who would be his colleague on the Committee of Public Safety, was also a member. In
1788, he took part in a discussion of how the French provincial
government should be elected, showing clearly and forcefully in his Addresse à la nation artésienne that
if the former mode of election by the members of the provincial estates
were again adopted, the new Estates-General would not represent the
people of France. It is possible he addressed this issue so that he
could have a chance to take part in the proceedings and thus change the
policies of the monarchy. King Louis XVI later
announced new elections for all provinces, thus allowing Robespierre to
run for the position of deputy for the Third Estate. Although
the leading members of the corporation were elected, Robespierre, their
chief opponent, succeeded in getting elected with them. In the assembly
of the bailliage rivalry ran still higher, but Robespierre had begun to make his mark in politics with the Avis aux habitants de la campagne (Arras,
1789). With this he secured the support of the country electors and,
although only thirty, comparatively poor and lacking patronage, he was
elected fifth deputy of the Third Estate of Artois to the Estates-General. When Robespierre arrived at Versailles,
he was relatively unknown, but he soon became part of the
representative National Assembly which then transformed into the
Constituent Assembly. While
the Constituent Assembly occupied itself with drawing up a
constitution, Robespierre turned from the assembly of provincial
lawyers and wealthy bourgeois to the people of Paris. He was a frequent speaker in the Constituent Assembly; he voiced many ideas for the Declaration of the Rights of Man and Constitutional Provisions, often with great success. He was eventually recognized as second only to Pétion de Villeneuve - if second he was - as a leader of the small body of the extreme left; "the thirty voices" as Mirabeau contemptuously called them. Robespierre soon became involved with the new Society of the Friends of the Constitution, known eventually as the Jacobin Club. This had consisted originally of the deputies from Brittany only. After the Assembly moved to Paris, the Club began to admit various leaders of the Parisian bourgeoisie to
its membership. As time went on, many of the more intelligent artisans
and small shopkeepers became members of the club. Among such men,
Robespierre found a sympathetic audience. As the wealthier bourgeois of
Paris and right-wing deputies seceded from the club of 1789, the influence of the old leaders of the Jacobins, such as Barnave, Duport, Alexandre de Lameth, diminished. When they, alarmed at the progress of the Revolution, founded the club of the Feuillants in 1791, the left, including Robespierre and his friends, dominated the Jacobin Club. On
15 May 1791, Robespierre proposed and carried the motion that no deputy
who sat in the Constituent could sit in the succeeding Assembly, his
only successful proposition in this assembly. The flight on 20 June, and subsequent arrest at Varennes of Louis XVI and
his family resulted in Robespierre declaring himself at the Jacobin
Club to be "ni monarchiste ni républicain" ("neither monarchist nor republican"). But this was not unusual; very few at this point were avowed republicans. After the massacre of the Champ de Mars on 17 July 1791, in order to be nearer to the Assembly and the Jacobins, he moved to live in the house of Maurice Duplay,
a cabinet maker residing in the Rue Saint-Honoré and an ardent
admirer of Robespierre. Robespierre lived there (with two short
intervals excepted) until his death. In fact, according to some
sources, he became engaged to the eldest daughter of his host, Éléonore Duplay. On 30 September, on the dissolution of the Constituent Assembly,
the people of Paris crowned Pétion and Robespierre as the two
incorruptible patriots in an attempt to honor their purity of
principles, their modest ways of living, and their refusal of bribes. With
the dissolution of the Assembly he returned for a short visit to Arras,
where he met with a triumphant reception. In November he returned to
Paris to take the position of Public Prosecutor of Paris. On February 1792, Jacques Pierre Brissot, one of the leaders of the Girondist party in the Legislative Assembly, urged that France should declare war against Austria. Marat and Robespierre opposed him, because they feared the possibility of militarism, which might then be turned to the advantage of the reactionary forces.
Robespierre was also convinced the stability of the internal country
was more important; he was suspicious of traitors and
counter-revolutionaries hidden among the people. This
opposition from expected allies irritated the Girondists and political
rivalry arose between them. In April 1792, Robespierre resigned the
post of public prosecutor of Versailles, which he had officially held, but never practiced, since February, and started a journal, Le Défenseur de la Constitution, in his own defence against the accusations of the Girondist leaders. Because of his popularity, his reputation for virtue and his influence over the Jacobin Club, the strongmen of the Commune of Paris were
glad to have Robespierre's aid in the face of food riots and
factionalism. On 16 August, Robespierre presented the petition of the
Commune to the Legislative Assembly, demanding the establishment of a revolutionary tribunal and the summoning of a Convention. Robespierre has often been reproached with failing to stop the September Massacres. In September, he was elected first deputy for Paris to the National Convention. Robespierre and his allies took the benches high at the back of the hall, giving them the label 'the Montagnards'; below them were the 'Manège' of the Girondists and then 'the Plain' of the independents. At
the Convention, the Girondists immediately attacked Robespierre. On 26
September, the Girondist Marc-David Lasource accused Robespierre of
wanting to form a dictatorship. Rumours spread that Robespierre, Marat and Danton were plotting to establish a triumvirate. On 29 October, Louvet de Couvrai attacked Robespierre in a speech, possibly written by Madame Roland. On 5 November, Robespierre defended himself and denounced the federalist plans
of the Girondists. Robespierre was one of the most popular orators in
the Convention and his carefully prepared speeches often made a deep
impression. In
December 1792, personal disputes were overshadowed by the question of
the King's trial. In this instance, Robespierre held the position that
the King must be executed, whereas previously he had opposed the death
penalty. The position of Robespierre was that if one man’s life had to
be sacrificed to save the Revolution, there was no alternative: it had
to be that of King Louis. Robespierre
argued that the King, having betrayed the people when he tried to flee
the country, and by being a king in the first place, posed a danger to
the State as a unifying entity to enemies of the Republic. After
the King's execution, the influence of Robespierre, Danton, and the
pragmatic politicians increased at the expense of the Girondists. The
Girondists refused to have anything more to do with Danton and because
of this the government became more divided. In May 1793, Desmoulins, at the behest of Robespierre and Danton, published his Histoire des Brissotins, an elaboration on the earlier article Jean-Pierre Brissot, démasqué, a scathing attack on Brissot and the Girondists. Maximin Isnard declared
that Paris must be destroyed if it came out against the provincial
deputies. Robespierre preached a moral "insurrection against the
corrupt deputies" at the Jacobin Club. On 2 June, a large crowd of
armed men from the Commune of Paris came to the Convention and arrested thirty-two deputies on charges of counter-revolutionary activities. After
the fall of the monarchy, France faced more food riots, large popular
insurrections and accusations of treasonous acts by those previously
considered patriots. A stable government was needed to quell the chaos. On 11 March, a Revolutionary Tribunal was established in Paris. On 6 April, the nine-member Committee of Public Safety replaced
the larger Committee of General Defense. On 27 July 1793, the
Convention elected Robespierre to the Committee, although he had not
sought the position. The Committee of General Security began to manage the country's internal police. Though
nominally all members of the committee were equal, Robespierre has
often been regarded as the dominant force and, as such, the de facto dictator of the country. He is also seen as the driving force behind the Reign of Terror—Louis-Sébastien Mercier called
him a "Sanguinocrat"—although, after 1794, other participants may have
exaggerated his role to downplay their own contribution. As an orator,
he praised revolutionary government and argued that the Terror was
necessary, laudable and inevitable. It was Robespierre's belief that
the Republic and virtue were of necessity inseparable. He reasoned that
the Republic could only be saved by the virtue of its citizens, and
that the Terror was virtuous because it attempted to maintain the
Revolution and the Republic. Robespierre’s
popularity and appeal to the community came out mostly in the way that
he spoke. His speeches were exceptional, and he had the power to change
the views of almost any audience. Robespierre
believed that the Terror was a time of discovering and revealing the
enemy within Paris, within France, the enemy that hid in the safety of
apparent patriotism. Because
he believed that the Revolution was still in progress, and in danger of
being sabotaged, he made every attempt to instill in the populace and
Convention the urgency of carrying out the Terror. In his Report and
others, he brought tales and fears of traitors, monarchists, and
saboteurs throughout the Republic and also the Convention itself. Robespierre
expanded the traditional list of the Revolution's enemies to include
moderates and "false revolutionaries". In Robespierre's understanding,
these were not only ignorant of the dangers facing the Republic, but
also in many cases disguised themselves as active contributors to the
Revolution, who simply repeated the work of others, or even impeded the
progress of the patriots. Robespierre
saw no room for mercy in his Terror, stating that "slowness of
judgments is equal to impunity" and "uncertainty of punishment
encourages all the guilty". Throughout his Report on the Principles of Political Morality,
Robespierre assailed any stalling of action in defence of the Republic.
A staunch believer in the
teachings of Rousseau, Robespierre believed that it was his duty as a
public servant to push the Revolution forward, and that the only
rational way to do that was to defend it on all fronts. The Report did
not merely call for blood but also expounded many of the original ideas
of the 1789 Revolution, such as political equality, suffrage, and
abolition of privileges. Despite executing a good number of his fellow
revolutionaries, Robespierre was still one of them in his theory, even
if his practice was questionable. In the winter of 1793–1794, a majority of the Committee decided that the Hébertist party would
have to perish or its opposition within the Committee would overshadow
the other factions due to its influence in the Commune of Paris.
Robespierre also had personal reasons for disliking the
Hébertists for their "atheism" and "bloodthirstiness", which he associated with the old aristocracy. In
early 1794, he broke with Danton who had more moderate views on the
Terror and had Camille Desmoulins protest against it in the third issue
of Le Vieux Cordelier. Robespierre considered an end of the Terror as meaning the loss of political power he hoped to use to create the Republic of Virtue. Subsequently, he joined in attacks on the Dantonists and the Hébertists. Robespierre charged his opponents with complicity with foreign powers. From
13 February to 13 March 1794, Robespierre withdrew from active business
on the Committee due to illness. On 15 March, he reappeared in the
Convention. Hébert and nineteen of his followers were arrested
on 19 March and guillotined on 24 March. Danton, Desmoulins and their friends were arrested on 30 March and guillotined on 5 April. After
Danton's execution, Robespierre worked to develop his own policies and
hoped that the Convention would pass whatever measures he might
dictate. He used his influence over the Jacobin Club to dominate the
Commune of Paris through his followers. Two of them, Jean-Baptiste
Fleuriot-Lescot and Claude-François de Payan, were elected mayor and procurator of the Commune respectively. Robespierre tried to influence the army through his follower Louis de Saint-Just,
whom he sent on a mission to the frontier. In Paris, Robespierre
increased the activity of the Terror. To secure his aims, another ally
on the Committee, Georges Couthon, introduced and carried on 10 June the drastic Law of 22 Prairial. Under this law, the Tribunal became a simple court of condemnation
without need of witnesses. The result of this was that until
Robespierre's death, 1,285 victims were guillotined in Paris. Robespierre's
desire for revolutionary change was not limited to the political realm.
He sought to instill a spiritual resurgence in the French nation based
on his Deist beliefs. Accordingly, on 7 May 1794, Robespierre had a decree passed by the Convention that established a Supreme Being (Culte de la Raison et de l'Être suprême). The notion of the Supreme Being was based on ideas that Jean-Jacques Rousseau had outlined in The Social Contract. In honour of the Supreme Being, a celebration was held on 8 June, which was also the “high holy day of Pentecost.” The festivities were held in the Champ de Mars, and in honor of the Festival it was renamed the Champ de la Réunion ("Field of Reunion") for that day. This was most likely in honor of the Champ de Mars Massacre where the Republicans first rallied against the power of the Crown. Robespierre,
as President of the Convention, walked first in the festival procession
and delivered a speech in which he emphasised that his concept of a
Supreme Being, which he termed a radical Democrat, was far different
from the traditional God of Christianity. Throughout
the "Festival of the Supreme Being", Robespierre was beaming with joy;
not even the negativity of his colleagues could disrupt his delight. He
was able to speak of the things about which he was truly passionate,
including Virtue and Nature,
typical deist beliefs, and, of course, his disagreements with atheism.
Everything was arranged to the exact specifications that had been
previously set before the ceremony; the ominous and symbolic guillotine
had been moved to the original standing place of the Bastille, all of the people were placed in the appropriate area designated to them, and everyone was dressed accordingly. Not
only was everything going smoothly, but the Festival was also
Robespierre’s first appearance in the public eye as an actual leader
for the people, and also, as President of the Convention to which he
had been elected only four days earlier. While
for some it was an excitement to see him at his finest, many other
leaders involved in the Festival agreed that Robespierre had taken
things a bit too far. Multiple sources state that Robespierre came down
the mountain in a way that resembled Moses as the leader of the people, and one of his colleagues, Jacques-Alexis Thuriot,
was heard saying, “Look at the bugger; it’s not enough for him to be
master, he has to be God.” While these words may have been a simple
release of resentment at the time, this same idea would come back in an
attempt to remove Robespierre from his high and lofty position in the
very near future. Marc-Guillaume Alexis Vadier was
not one of Robespierre’s devotees, and was actually attempting to find
something that Robespierre had done wrong. Vadier was on a mission to
attack Robespierre and his faith, and was also trying to bring down
Robespierre’s political stature as well. This is when he found Catherine Théot, who was a seventy-eight-year old, self declared “prophetess” who had, at one point, been imprisoned in the Bastille. By Théot stating that he was the “herald of the Last Days, prophet of the New Dawn,” (due to the fact that his Festival had fallen on the Pentecost,
which she claimed would be the day revealing a “divine manifestation”)
Catherine Théot made it seem as though Robespierre had made
these claims himself to her. Many of her followers were supporters or
friends of Robespierre as well, which made it seem as though he was
attempting to create a new religion with himself as its god. While
Robespierre had nothing to do with Catherine Théot or her
followers, many assumed that he was on his way to dictatorship, and it
sent a current of fear throughout the Convention, which led to his
downfall the following July. On
25 May, only two days after the attempted assassination of Collot d’
Herbois, Robespierre’s life was also in danger as a young girl by the
name of Cécile Renault approached him with two small knives in an attempt to murder him. At this point in time, the decree of 22 Prairial was introduced to the public without the consultation from the Committee of General Security, which in turn doubled the amount of executions permitted by the Committee of Public Safety. This
law permitted executions to be carried out even under simple suspicion
of citizens thought to be counter-revolutionaries without extensive
trials. By allowing this law to be passed, the people of France began
to question Robespierre and the Committee because of the fact that they
were executing people for seemingly meaningless reasons, and also
because they had passed a law without the help of the Committee of General Security. This was part of the beginning of Robespierre’s downfall. Reports were coming into Paris about excesses committed by the envoys sent en-mission to the provinces particularly Jean-Lambert Tallien in Bordeaux and Joseph Fouché in
Lyons. Robespierre had them recalled to Paris to account for their
actions and expelled from the Jacobins club. However they evaded
arrest. Fouché spent the evenings moving house to house with a
spurious whispering campaign among members of the Convention warning
them that Robespierre was after them and set about organising a coup
d'état. Robespierre appeared at the Convention on 26 July (8th Thermidor, year II, according to the Revolutionary calendar),
and delivered a two-hour-long speech. He defended himself against
charges of dictatorship and tyranny, and then proceeded to warn of a conspiracy against
the Republic. Robespierre implied that members of the Convention were a
part of this conspiracy, though when pressed he refused to provide any
names. The speech however alarmed members particularly given
Fouché's warnings. These members who felt that Robespierre was
alluding to them tried to prevent the speech from being printed, and a
bitter debate ensued until Bertrand Barère forced an end to it. Later that evening, Robespierre delivered the same speech again at the Jacobin Club, where it was very well received. The next day, Saint-Just began
to give a speech in support of Robespierre. However, those who saw him
working on his speech the night before expected accusations to arise
from it. He only had time to give a small part of his speech before Jean-Lambert Tallien interrupted
him. While the accusations began to pile up, Saint-Just remained
uncharacteristically silent. Robespierre then attempted to secure the
tribune to speak but his voice was shouted down. Robespierre soon found
himself at a loss for words after one deputy called for his arrest and
another, Marc-Guillaume Alexis Vadier,
gave a mocking impression of him. When one deputy realised
Robespierre's inability to respond, the man shouted, "The blood of
Danton chokes him!" The Convention ordered the arrest of Robespierre, his brother Augustin, Couthon, Saint-Just, François Hanriot and Le Bas.
Troops from the Commune, under General Coffinhal, arrived to free the
prisoners and then marched against the Convention itself. The
Convention responded by ordering troops of its own under Barras to
be called out. When the Commune's troops heard the news of this, order
began to break down, and Hanriot ordered his remaining troops to
withdraw to the Hôtel de Ville, where Robespierre and his supporters also gathered. The Convention declared them to be outlaws,
meaning that upon verification the fugitives could be executed within
twenty-four hours without a trial. As the night went on, the forces of
the Commune deserted the Hôtel de Ville and,
at around two in the morning, those of the Convention under the command
of Barras arrived there. In order to avoid capture, Augustin
Robespierre threw himself out of a window; Couthon was found lying at
the bottom of a staircase; Le Bas committed suicide;
another radical jumped out of the window, only to break both of his
legs; yet another shot himself in the head. Robespierre tried to kill
himself with a pistol but only managed to shatter his jaw, although some sources claimed that Robespierre was shot by Charles-André Merda. For
the remainder of the night, Robespierre was moved to a table in the
room of the Committee of Public Safety where he awaited execution. He
lay on the table bleeding abundantly until a doctor was brought in to
fix up his jaw. Although Robespierre was known for his speeches, the
last words that have been recorded of him saying are, “Merci,
monsieur,” to a man that had kindly given him a handkerchief to sop up
some of the blood from his face and his clothing. Later, Robespierre was held in the same containment chamber where Marie Antoinette, the wife of King Louis XVI, had been held. The next day, 28 July 1794, Robespierre was guillotined without trial in the Place de la Révolution.
His brother Augustin, Couthon, Saint-Just, Hanriot and twelve other
followers, among them the cobbler Simon, were also executed. Only
Robespierre was guillotined face-up. When clearing Robespierre's neck
the executioner tore off the bandage that was holding his shattered jaw
in place, producing an agonising scream until the fall of the blade
silenced him. Together with those executed with him, he was buried in a common grave at the newly-opened Errancis cemetery (cimetière des Errancis) (March 1794-April 1797) (now the Place de Goubeaux). Between 1844 and 1859 (probably in 1848), the remains of all those buried there were moved to the Catacombs of Paris. |