December 20, 2011 <Back to Index>
PAGE SPONSOR |
Sir Robert Gordon Menzies, KT, AK, CH, FAA, FRS, QC (20 December 1894 – 15 May 1978), Australian politician, was the 12th and longest serving Prime Minister of Australia. His first term as Prime Minister commenced in 1939, after the death in office of the United Australia Party leader Joseph Lyons and a short term interim premiership by Sir Earle Page. His party narrowly won the 1940 election, which produced the first hung parliament in Australian history, with the support of independent MPs in the House. A year later, his government was brought down by those same MPs crossing the floor. He spent eight years in opposition, during which he founded the Liberal Party of Australia. He again became Prime Minister at the 1949 election, and he then dominated Australian politics until his retirement in 1966. Menzies
was renowned as a brilliant speaker, both on the floor of Parliament
and on the hustings;
his speech "The Forgotten
People" is an example of his oratorical skills. Throughout
his life and career, Menzies held strong beliefs in the Monarchy and in traditional ties
with Britain. In 1963 Menzies was invested as the first and only
Australian Knight of the Order of the
Thistle. Menzies is regarded highly in Prime
Ministerial opinion polls and
is very highly regarded in Australian society for his tenures as Prime
Minister. Robert
Gordon Menzies was born to James Menzies and Kate Menzies (née
Sampson) in
Jeparit, a town in the Wimmera region of western Victoria,
on 20 December 1894. His father James was a storekeeper, the son of Scottish crofters who had immigrated to
Australia in the mid 1850s in the wake of the Victorian gold
rush. His maternal grandfather, John Sampson, was a Cornish miner from Penzance who also came to seek his
fortune on the gold fields, in Ballarat. His
father and one of his uncles had been members of the Victorian
Parliament, while another uncle had represented Wimmera in the House of
Representatives. He was proud of his Highland ancestry – his
enduring nickname, Ming,
came from /ˈmɪŋəs/,
the Scots — and his own preferred —
pronunciation of Menzies.
His middle name, Gordon, was given to him in honour and memory of Charles George
Gordon, a British army officer killed in Khartoum in 1885. Menzies
was first educated at a one room school, then later at private schools
in Ballarat and Melbourne (Wesley College),
and studied law at the University of
Melbourne graduating
in 1916. When World War I began,
Menzies was 19 years old and held a commission in the university's
militia unit. Menzies resigned his commission at the very time others
of his age and class clamoured to be allowed to enlist. It was later
stated that, since the family had made enough of a sacrifice to the war
with the enlistment of two of three eligible brothers, Menzies should
stay to finish his studies. Menzies
himself
never explained the reason why he chose not to enlist.
Subsequently he was prominent in undergraduate activities and won
academic prizes and declared himself to be a patriotic supporter of the
war and conscription. Menzies
was admitted to the Victorian Bar and to the High Court of Australia in
1918 and soon became one of Melbourne's leading lawyers after
establishing his own practice. In 1920 he married Pattie Leckie,
the daughter of federal Nationalist,
and later Liberal, MP, John Leckie. In 1928,
Menzies gave up his law practice to enter state parliament as a member
of the
Victorian Legislative Council from East Yarra
Province, representing the Nationalist
Party of Australia.
His candidacy was nearly defeated when a group of ex-servicemen
attacked him in the press for not having enlisted, but he survived this
crisis. The following year he shifted to the Legislative
Assembly as the
member for Nunawading.
Before the election, he founded the Young Nationalists as his party's
youth wing and served as its first president. He was Deputy Premier
of Victoria from May
1932 until July 1934. Menzies
transferred to federal politics in 1934, representing the United
Australia Party (UAP
-- the
Nationalists had merged with other non-Labor groups to form the UAP
during his tenure as a state parliamentarian) in the upper class
Melbourne electorate of Kooyong.
He was immediately appointed Attorney General and Minister for Industry
in the Lyons government. In 1937 he was appointed a Privy Councillor.
In late 1934 and early 1935 Menzies unsuccessfully prosecuted the Lyons
government's case for the attempted
exclusion from
Australia of
Egon Kisch,
a Czech Jewish communist. Because of this, some accused Menzies of
being pro-Nazi, whilst others saw it as an early example of his strong
opposition to communism. Following the outbreak of World War II Menzies found it necessary
to distance himself from the controversy by claiming Interior Minister Thomas Paterson was responsible since he
made the initial order to exclude Kisch. Animosity
developed between Page and Menzies which was aggravated when Page
became Acting Prime Minister during Lyons' illness after October 1938.
Menzies and Page attacked each other publicly. He later became deputy
leader of the UAP. His supporters said he was Lyons's natural
successor; his critics accused Menzies of wanting to push Lyons out, a
charge he denied. In 1938 his enemies ridiculed him as "Pig Iron Bob",
the result of his industrial battle with waterside workers who refused
to load scrap iron being sold to Imperial Japan.
In
1939, however, he resigned from the Cabinet in protest at
postponement of the national insurance scheme. With Lyons' sudden death
on 7 April 1939, Page became acting Prime Minister until the UAP could
elect a leader. On
18 April, Menzies was elected Leader of the UAP and was sworn in as
Prime Minister eight days later. A crisis arose almost immediately,
however, when Page refused to serve under him. In an extraordinary
personal attack in the House, Page accused Menzies of cowardice for not
having enlisted in the War, and of treachery to Lyons. Menzies then
formed a minority
government. When Page was deposed as Country Party leader a few
months later, Menzies reformed the Coalition with Page's successor, Archie Cameron. - Menzies
radio broadcast to the nation on 3 September 1939 informing Australia
that the country was at war with Germany and her allies. In
September 1939, Menzies found himself a wartime leader of a small
nation of 7 million people that depended on Britain for defence against
the looming threat of the Japanese Empire, with 100 million people, a
very powerful military, and an aggressive foreign policy that looked
south. He did his best to rally the country, but the bitter memories of
the disillusionment which followed the First World War made this
difficult. Added to this was the fact that Menzies had not served in
that war, and that as Attorney General and Deputy Prime Minister,
Menzies had made an official visit to Germany in 1938, and like his
Opposition at the time, supported Neville
Chamberlain's policy of Appeasement.
At
the 1940 election, the UAP was nearly defeated, and Menzies'
government survived only thanks to the support of two independent MPs, Arthur Coles and Alex Wilson.
The Australian
Labor Party (ALP),
under John Curtin,
refused
Menzies' offer to form a war coalition, and also opposed using
the Australian army for a European war, preferring to keep it at home
to defend Australia. The ALP did agree to participate in the Advisory War
Council, however. Menzies sent the bulk of the army to help the
British in the Middle East and Singapore, and told Winston
Churchill the
Royal Navy should strengthen its Far Eastern forces. In
1941 Menzies spent months in Britain discussing war strategy with
Churchill and other leaders, while his position at home deteriorated.
The Australian historian David Day has
suggested that Menzies hoped to replace Churchill as British Prime
Minister, and that he had some support in Britain for this. Other
Australian writers, such as Gerard Henderson,
have
rejected this theory. When Menzies came home, he found he had lost all
support, and was forced to resign as Prime Minister. However, the
UAP was so bereft of leadership that it was forced to allow the Country
Party leader, Arthur Fadden,
to
become Prime Minister even though the Country Party was the junior
partner in the Coalition. Menzies was very bitter about what he saw as
this betrayal by his colleagues, and almost left politics. However, he
was prevailed upon to remain UAP leader and Minister for
Defence Co-ordination in
Fadden's government. Extract; The Forgotten
People, Robert Menzies, 22 May 1942; Fadden's
government was defeated in Parliament later in 1941, and Labor formed a
government under John Curtin. Menzies argued that he should become Leader of the
Opposition, but most of his colleagues favoured Fadden. Menzies
resigned the leadership in disgust and was succeeded by Billy Hughes.
However, Menzies remained an opposition frontbencher under Fadden. In
1943 Curtin won a huge election victory. Hughes resigned as UAP leader,
and Menzies returned to the leadership. Fadden yielded the post of
Opposition Leader back to Menzies as well. During 1944 Menzies held a
series of meetings at 'Ravenscraig' an old homestead in Aspley to
discuss forming a new anti-Labor party to replace the moribund UAP.
This was the Liberal Party, which was launched in early 1945 with
Menzies as leader. But Labor was firmly entrenched in power and in 1946
Curtin's successor, Ben Chifley,
was comfortably re-elected. Comments that "we can't win with Menzies"
began to circulate in the conservative press. Over the
next few years, however, the anti-communist atmosphere of the early Cold War began
to erode Labor's support. In 1947, Chifley announced that he intended
to nationalise Australia's private banks, arousing intense middle class
opposition which Menzies successfully exploited. The 1949 coal strike,
engineered by the Communist Party,
also played into Menzies' hands. In the December 1949
election,
Menzies won power for the second time in a massive landslide, scoring a
48-seat swing — still the largest defeat of a sitting government at the
federal level in Australia. In 1950 Menzies was awarded the Legion of Merit (Chief Commander) by U.S.
President Harry S. Truman for "exceptionally
meritorious conduct in the performance of outstanding services 1941 –
1944 and December 1949 – July 1950". Although
Menzies had a comfortable majority in the House, the ALP controlled
Senate made life very difficult for him. In 1951 Menzies introduced
legislation to ban the Communist Party, hoping that the Senate would
reject it and give him an excuse for a double
dissolution election,
but Labor let the bill pass. It was subsequently ruled
unconstitutional by
the High Court.
But when the Senate rejected his banking bill, he called a double
dissolution and at
the election won control of both Houses. Later in
1951 Menzies decided to hold a referendum on
the question of changing the Constitution to permit the parliament to
make laws in respect of Communists and Communism where he said this was
necessary for the security of the Commonwealth. If passed, this would
have given a government the power to introduce a bill proposing to ban
the Communist Party (although whether it would have passed the Senate
is an open question). The new Labor leader, Dr H.V. Evatt,
campaigned
against the referendum on civil liberties grounds, and it
was narrowly defeated. This was one of Menzies' few electoral
miscalculations. He sent Australian troops to the Korean War and maintained a close
alliance with the United States. Economic
conditions, however, deteriorated, and Evatt was confident of winning
the 1954 elections. Shortly before the elections, Menzies announced
that a Soviet diplomat in Australia Vladimir Petrov,
had
defected, and that there was evidence of a Soviet spy ring in
Australia, including members of Evatt's staff. Evatt felt compelled to
state on the floor of Parliament that he'd personally written Soviet
Foreign Minister Vyacheslav
Molotov, who assured him there were no Soviet spy rings in
Australia. This Cold War scare enabled Menzies to
win the election; although Labor won a majority of the two party
preferred vote,
it came up eight seats short of toppling the Coalition. Evatt accused
Menzies of arranging Petrov's defection, but this has since been
disproved: he had simply taken advantage of it. The
aftermath of the 1954 election caused a split in the Labor Party, with
several anti-Communist members from Victoria defecting to form the Australian
Labor Party (Anti-Communist).
The new party directed its preferences to the Liberals, and Menzies was
comfortably re-elected over Evatt in 1955. Menzies was reelected almost
as easily in 1958, again with the help of preferences from what had
become the Democratic
Labor Party. By this time the post-war economic recovery was in
full swing, fuelled
by massive immigration and the growth in housing and manufacturing that
this produced. Prices for Australia's agricultural exports were also
high, ensuring rising incomes. Labor's
new leader, Arthur Calwell,
gave
Menzies a scare after an ill-judged squeeze on credit – an
effort to restrain inflation – caused a rise in unemployment. At
the 1961 election Menzies
was returned with a majority of only two seats. But Menzies was able to
exploit Labor's divisions over the Cold War and the American alliance,
and win an increased majority in the 1963 election. An
incident in which Calwell was photographed standing outside a South
Canberra hotel while the ALP Federal
Executive (dubbed
by
Menzies the "36 faceless men") was determining policy also
contributed to the 1963 victory. This was the first "television
election," and Menzies, although nearly 70, proved a master of the new
medium. Menzies' policy speech was televised on 12 November 1963, a
method that "had never before been used in Australia". The effect of this form of
political communication was studied by Colin Hughes and John Western,
who published their findings in 1966. This was itself the first such
detailed study in Australia. In 1963,
Menzies was appointed a Knight of the Order of the
Thistle (KT),[9] the
order being chosen in recognition of his Scottish heritage. He is the
only Australian ever appointed to this order, although three British governors-general
of Australia (Lord Hopetoun; Sir Ronald
Munro Ferguson, later Lord Novar; and Prince Henry,
Duke of Gloucester)
were members. He was the second of only two Australian prime ministers
to be knighted during their term of office (the first prime minister Edmund Barton was knighted during his
term in 1902). In 1965,
Menzies committed Australian troops to the Vietnam War,
and also to reintroduce conscription.
These moves were initially popular, but later became a problem for his
successors. Despite
his pragmatic acceptance of the new power balance in the Pacific after
World War II and his strong support for the American alliance, he
publicly professed continued admiration for links with Britain,
exemplified by his admiration for Queen Elizabeth
II,
and famously described himself as "British to the bootstraps". Over the
decade, Australia's ardour for Britain and the monarchy faded somewhat,
but Menzies's had not. At a function attended by the Queen at
Parliament House, Canberra, in 1963, Menzies quoted the Elizabethan poet Thomas Ford, "I did but see her
passing by, and yet I love her till I die". Menzies
retired on Australia Day 1966,
ending 38 years as an elected official. To date, he is the last
Australian Prime Minister to leave office on his own terms. He was
succeeded as Liberal Party leader and Prime Minister by his former
Treasurer, Harold Holt.
Although the coalition remained in power for almost another seven years
(until the 1972 Federal
election), it did so under four different Prime Ministers. On
his retirement he became the thirteenth Chancellor of his old
University of Melbourne, and remained the head of the University from
March 1967 until March 1972. Much earlier in 1942, he had received the
first honorary degree of Doctor of Laws of Melbourne University. His
responsibility for the revival and growth of university life in
Australia was widely acknowledged by the award of honorary degrees in
the Universities of Queensland, Adelaide, Tasmania, New South Wales,
and the Australian National University and by thirteen universities in
Canada, the U.S.A. and Britain, including Oxford and Cambridge. Many
learned institutions, including the Royal College
of Surgeons (Hon.
FRCS) and the Royal
Australasian College of Physicians (Hon. FRACP), elected him
to Honorary Fellowships, and the Australian
Academy of Science, for which he supported its establishment in
1954, made him a fellow (FAAS) in 1958. In July
1966 the Queen appointed Menzies to the ancient office of Lord Warden of
the Cinque Ports and
Constable of Dover Castle,
taking official residence at Walmer Castle during
his annual visits to Britain. He toured the United States giving
lectures, and he published two volumes of memoirs. At the end of 1966
Menzies took up a scholar-in-residence position at the University of
Virginia.
Menzies encountered some public tribulation in retirement; however,
when he suffered strokes in 1968 and 1971, he faded from public view. Menzies
died from a heart attack in Melbourne in 1978 and
was accorded a state funeral, held in Scots' Church,
Melbourne, at which Prince Charles represented Queen Elizabeth
II. Menzies
was Prime Minister for a total of 18 years, five months, and 12 days,
by far the longest term of any Australian Prime Minister, and during
his second term he dominated Australian politics as no one else has
ever done. He managed to live down the failures of his first term in
office, and to rebuild the conservative side of politics from the nadir
it hit in 1943. Menzies also did much to develop higher education in
Australia, and he also made the increasing development of Canberra one of his big projects.
However, it can also be noted that while retaining government on each
occasion, Menzies lost the two-party-preferred
vote in 1940, 1954, and 1961. He
was the only Australian Prime Minister to recommend the appointment of
four governors general (Sir William Slim, and Lords Dunrossil, De
L'Isle, and Casey). Only two other Prime Ministers have ever chosen
more than one governor general. (Malcolm Fraser chose Sir Zelman Cowen
and Sir Ninian Stephen; and John Howard chose Peter Hollingworth and
Michael Jeffery.) Critics
say that Menzies's success was mainly due to the good luck of the long
post-war boom and his manipulation of the anti-communist fears of the
Cold War years, both of which he exploited with great skill. He was
also crucially aided by the crippling dissent within the Labor Party in
the 1950s and especially by the ALP split of
1954. Several
books have been filled with anecdotes about him and with his many witty
remarks. While he was speaking in Williamstown,
Victoria, in 1954, a heckler shouted, "I wouldn’t vote for you
if you were the Archangel
Gabriel" – to which Menzies coolly replied "If I were the
Archangel Gabriel, I’m afraid you wouldn't be in my constituency." Planning
for an official biography of Menzies began soon after his death, but it
was long delayed by Dame Pattie Menzies' protection of her husband's
reputation and her refusal to co-operate with the appointed biographer, Frances McNicoll.
In 1991, the Menzies family appointed Professor A.W. Martin to write a biography, which
appeared in two volumes, in 1993 and 1999. |