May 07, 2011 <Back to Index>
PAGE SPONSOR |
Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky (Russian: Пётр Ильич Чайковский; often Peter Ilich Tchaikovsky in English; May 7, 1840 [O.S. April 25] – November 6, 1893 [O.S. October 25]) was a Russian composer of the Romantic era. His wide ranging output includes symphonies, operas, ballets, instrumental and chamber music and songs. He wrote some of the most popular concert and theatrical music in the classical repertoire, including the ballets Swan Lake, The Sleeping Beauty and The Nutcracker, the 1812 Overture, his First Piano Concerto, his last three numbered symphonies, and the opera Eugene Onegin. Born into
a middle-class family, Tchaikovsky was educated for a career as a civil
servant, despite his obvious musical precocity. He pursued a musical
career against the wishes of his family, entering the Saint
Petersburg
Conservatory in
1862 and graduating in 1865. This formal, Western oriented training set
him apart from the contemporary nationalistic movement embodied by the
influential group of young Russian composers known as The
Five, with whom Tchaikovsky's professional relationship was mixed. Although
he enjoyed many popular successes, Tchaikovsky was never emotionally
secure, and his life was punctuated by personal crises and periods of
depression. Contributory factors were his suppressed homosexuality and fear of exposure, his
disastrous marriage, and the sudden collapse of the one enduring
relationship of his adult life, his 13-year association with the
wealthy widow Nadezhda von
Meck. Amid private turmoil Tchaikovsky's public reputation
grew; he was honored by the Tsar, awarded a lifetime pension and lauded
in the concert halls of the world. His sudden death at the age of 53 is
generally ascribed to cholera,
but
some attribute it to suicide. Although
perennially popular with concert audiences across the world,
Tchaikovsky's music was often dismissed by critics in the early and
mid 20th century as being vulgar and lacking in elevated thought. By the end of the 20th
century, however, Tchaikovsky's status as a significant composer was
generally regarded as secure. Pyotr
Ilyich Tchaikovsky was born in Votkinsk,
a
small town in present day Udmurtia,
formerly
province of Vyatka in the Russian
Empire, to a family with a long line of military service. Ilya
Petrovich Tchaikovsky, his father, was an engineer who served as a
lieutenant colonel in the Department of Mines and manager of the famed
Kamsko-Votkinsk Ironworks. The composer's mother,
Alexandra Andreyevna née d'Assier, 18 years her husband's
junior, was of partial French ancestry, and was the
second of Ilya's three wives. Tchaikovsky had four
brothers (Nikolai, Ippolit, and twins Anatoly and Modest),
and
a sister, Alexandra. He also had a half-sister Zinaida from his
father's first marriage. Tchaikovsky
was
particularly close to Alexandra and the twins. Anatoly later
established a prominent legal career, while Modest became a dramatist, librettist,
and
translator. Alexandra
married
Lev Davydov and had seven children, one
of whom, "Bob",
"[became]
a central figure in the composer's final years". The Davydovs provided the
only real family life Tchaikovsky knew as an adult, and their estate in
Kamenka, Ukraine, became a welcome refuge for him during his years of
wandering. In 1843,
due to the growth in family responsibilities, Tchaikovsky's
parents hired
a French governess, Fanny Dürbach, a 22 year old experienced
teacher who, Modest later wrote, "knew both French and German equally
well, and whose morals were strictly Protestant". While Dürbach had been
hired to look after Tchaikovsky's elder brother Nikolai and a
Tchaikovsky niece, it was not long before Tchaikovsky became curious
about the young woman and, as biographer Anthony
Holden wrote,
"wormed his way into Fanny Dürbach's affections, and thus into her
classes". Dürbach's love and
affection for her charge is said to have provided a counter to
Tchaikovsky's mother, who is described by Holden as a cold, unhappy,
distant parent not given to displays of physical affection. However, Tchaikovsky
scholar Alexander Poznansky wrote that the mother doted on her son. Tchaikovsky
began
piano lessons at the age of five. A precocious pupil, he could
read music as adeptly as his teacher within three years. His parents
were initially supportive of his musical talents, hiring a tutor,
buying an orchestrion (a form of barrel organ
that could imitate elaborate orchestral effects), and encouraging his
study of the piano. However, his parents'
passion for his musical talent soon cooled, and, in 1850, the family
decided to send Tchaikovsky to the Imperial
School
of Jurisprudence in Saint
Petersburg. The school mainly served the lesser nobility, and would
prepare him for a career as a civil servant. As the minimum age for
acceptance was 12, Tchaikovsky was required to spend two years boarding
at the Imperial School of Jurisprudence's preparatory school,
800 miles (1,300 km) from his family. Once those two years had
passed, Tchaikovsky transferred to the Imperial School of Jurisprudence
to begin a seven-year course of studies. On June
25, 1854 Tchaikovsky suffered the shock of his mother's death from cholera.
Tchaikovsky
authority David
Brown calls it "the crucial event of [Tchaikovsky's] years at the School of Jurisprudence", and noted that "it was
certainly shattering." Tchaikovsky bemoaned the
loss of his mother for the rest of his life, and admitted that it had
"a huge influence on the way things turned out for me." He was so affected that he
was unable to inform Fanny Dürbach until two years after the fact. At the age of 40,
approximately 26 years after his mother's death, Tchaikovsky wrote to
his patroness, Nadezhda
von
Meck, "Every moment of that appalling day is as vivid to me as
though it were yesterday." However,
within
a month of his mother's death he was making his first serious efforts at composition, a waltz in her memory.
Tchaikovsky's father, who also became sick with cholera at this time
but made a full recovery, immediately sent the boy back to school in
hope that the classwork would occupy his mind. To make up for his sense of
isolation and to compensate for the loss in his family, Tchaikovsky
formed important friendships with fellow students, such as those with Aleksey
Apukhtin and
Vladimir Gerard, which lasted the rest of his life. He
may
have also been exposed to the allegedly widespread homosexual practices at the school.
Whether these were formative experiences or practices toward which the
composer would have gravitated normally, biographers agree that he may
have discovered his sexual orientation at this time. Music was
not considered a high priority at the School of Jurisprudence, but Tchaikovsky maintained
a connection to music extracurricularly, by regularly attending the
theater and the opera with other students. At this time, he was fond
of works by Rossini, Bellini, Verdi and Mozart.
He
was known to sit at the school's harmonium after choir practice and
improvise on whatever themes had just been sung. "We were amused,"
Vladimir Gerard later remembered, "but not imbued with any expectations
of his future glory." Piano manufacturer Franz
Becker made occasional visits to the school as a token music teacher.
This was the only formal music instruction Tchaikovsky received there.
In 1855, Ilya Tchaikovsky funded private lessons with Rudolph
Kündinger, a well-known piano teacher from Nuremberg.
Ilya
also questioned Kündinger about a musical career for his son.
Kündinger replied that while he was impressed with Tchaikovsky's
ability to improvise at the keyboard, nothing suggested a potential
composer or even a fine performer. Tchaikovsky was told to finish his
course and then try for a post in the Ministry of Justice. On June
10, 1859, at the age of 19, Tchaikovsky graduated from the School of
Jurisprudence with the rank of titular counsellor, a low rank on the
civil service ladder. On June 15, he was appointed to the Ministry of
Justice. Six months later he became a junior assistant and two months
after that, a senior assistant, where he remained for the rest of his
three-year civil service career. In 1861,
Tchaikovsky attended classes in music
theory organized by
the Russian
Musical
Society (RMS)
and taught by Nikolai
Zaremba. A year later he followed Zaremba to the new Saint
Petersburg
Conservatory. Tchaikovsky decided not to give up his
Ministry post "until I am quite certain that I am destined to be a
musician rather than a civil servant." From 1862 to 1865 he studied harmony and counterpoint with Zaremba, while Anton
Rubinstein, director and founder of the Conservatory, taught him
instrumentation and composition. In 1863, Tchaikovsky
abandoned his civil service career and began studying music full-time,
graduating from the Conservatory in December 1865. Though Rubinstein
was impressed by Tchaikovsky's musical talent, he and Zaremba later
clashed with the young composer over his First
Symphony, written after his graduation, when he submitted it to
them for their perusal. The symphony was given its first complete
performance in Moscow in February 1868, where it was well received. Rubinstein's
Western
musical orientation brought him into opposition with the nationalistic group
of
musicians known as The
Five. As Tchaikovsky was Rubinstein's best-known pupil, he became a
target for the group, especially for César
Cui. Cui's criticisms began with
a blistering review of a cantata Tchaikovsky
had written as
his graduation exercise from the Conservatory. Calling the piece
"feeble", Cui wrote that if Tchaikovsky had any gift for music, "then
at least somewhere or other [the cantata] would have broken through the
fetters of the Conservatoire". The effect of this review
on Tchaikovsky was devastating: "My vision grew dark, my head spun, and
I ran out of the café like a madman.... All day I wandered
aimlessly through the city, repeating, 'I'm sterile, insignificant, nothing will come out of me, I'm ungifted'". When in
1867, Rubinstein resigned as conductor from Saint Petersburg's Russian
Musical
Society orchestra,
he was replaced by composer Mily
Balakirev, leader of The Five. Tchaikovsky, now Professor of Music
Theory at the Moscow
Conservatory, had already promised his Dances of the Hay Maidens (which he later included in
his opera The
Voyevoda, as Characteristic
Dances) to the society. In submitting the manuscript (and perhaps
mindful of Cui's review of the graduation cantata), Tchaikovsky
included a note to Balakirev that ended with a request for a word of
encouragement should the Dances not be performed. Possibly
sensing
a new disciple in Tchaikovsky, Balakirev wrote "with
complete frankness" in his reply that he felt that Tchaikovsky was "a
fully fledged artist". These letters set the tone
for Tchaikovsky's relationship with Balakirev over the next two years.
In 1869, the two entered into a working relationship, the result being
Tchaikovsky's first recognised masterpiece, the fantasy-overture Romeo
and
Juliet, a work which The Five wholeheartedly embraced. Though,
personally, Tchaikovsky remained on friendly terms with most of The
Five, professionally, he was usually ambivalent about their music. Despite the collaboration
with Balakirev on the Romeo
and
Juliet fantasy-overture,
Tchaikovsky
made considerable efforts to ensure his musical
independence from the group as well as from the conservative faction at
the Saint Petersburg Conservatory. From 1867
to 1878, Tchaikovsky combined his professorial duties with music
criticism while
continuing to compose. Some of his best known works from this period include the First
Piano
Concerto, the Variations
on
a Rococo Theme for violoncello and orchestra, the Little
Russian and Fourth
Symphonies, the ballet Swan
Lake and the
opera Eugene
Onegin. The First Piano Concerto suffered an initial rejection
by its intended dedicatee, Anton Rubinstein's brother Nikolai,
though
he eventually championed the work. The work was subsequently
premiered in Boston in October 1875, played by Hans
von
Bülow, whose pianism had impressed Tchaikovsky during an
appearance in Moscow in March 1874. In
Moscow, teaching with Nikolai Rubinstein, Tchaikovsky gained his first
taste of famed appreciation. Introduced into the Artistic Circle, a
club founded by Rubinstein, Tchaikovsky enjoyed a sense of social
celebrity status among friends and fellow artists. However, over a five year
period, Tchaikovsky became frustrated with teaching and found himself
struggling financially. He gradually moved away from Rubinstein, to
maintain his independence from Rubinstein's renowned reputation. Nevertheless, while the
move to Moscow was bittersweet, filled with friendship, jealousy, and
inner struggles, it was successful from a
professional point of view. Tchaikovsky's musical works were frequently
performed, with few delays between their composition and first
performances, and the publication (after 1867) of songs and piano music
for the home market helped bolster the composer's popularity. In his
book, Tchaikovsky:
The Quest for the Inner Man, Poznansky showed that Tchaikovsky had
homosexual tendencies and that some of the composer's closest
relationships were with persons of the same sex. Tchaikovsky's servant
Aleksei Sofronov and the composer's nephew, Vladimir
"Bob"
Davydov, have been speculated as possible romantic interests. Tchaikovsky
dedicated
his Sixth Symphony, the Pathétique,
to
Davydov. The love theme from Romeo
and
Juliet is
generally considered to have been inspired by Eduard Zak. More
controversial than Tchaikovsky's reported sexual proclivities is how
comfortable the composer might have been with his sexual nature. After
reading all Tchaikovsky's letters (including unpublished ones),
Poznansky concludes that the composer "eventually came to see his
sexual peculiarities as an insurmountable and even natural part of his
personality ... without experiencing any serious psychological
damage." Relevant portions of his
brother Modest's autobiography, where he tells of his brother's sexual
orientation, have also been published. Modest, like Tchaikovsky,
was homosexual. Some letters previously
suppressed by Soviet censors, where Tchaikovsky openly speaks out about
his homosexuality, have been published in Russian, as well as by
Poznansky in English translation. However, biographer Anthony
Holden claims
British musicologist and scholar Henry Zajaczkowski's research "along
psychoanalytical lines" points instead to "a severe unconscious
inhibition by the composer of his sexual feelings": One
consequence of it may be sexual overindulgence as a kind of false
solution: the individual thereby persuades himself that he does accept
his sexual impulses. Complementing this and, also, as a psychological
defense mechanism, would be precisely the idolization by Tchaikovsky of
many of the young men of his circle [the self-styled "Fourth Suite"],
to which Poznansky himself draws attention. If the composer's response
to possible sexual objects was either to use and discard them or to
idolize them, it shows that he was unable to form an integrated, secure
relationship with another man. That, surely, was [Tchaikovsky's]
tragedy. Musicologist
and
historian Roland John Wiley suggests a third alternative, based on
Tchaikovsky's letters. He suggests that while Tchaikovsky experienced
"no unbearable guilt" over his homosexuality, he remained aware of the
negative consequences of that knowledge becoming public, especially of
the ramifications for his family. His decision to enter into
a heterosexual union and try to lead a double life was prompted by
several factors — the possibility of exposure, the willingness to please
his father, his own desire for a permanent home and his love of
children and family. While Tchaikovsky may have
been romantically active, the evidence for "sexual argot and passionate
encounter" is limited. He sought out the company
of homosexuals in his circle for extended periods, "associating openly
and establishing professional connections with them." Wiley adds, "Amateurish
criticism to the contrary, there is no warrant to assume, this period
[of his short lived marriage] excepted, that Tchaikovsky's sexuality
ever deeply impaired his inspiration, or made his music
idiosyncratically confessional or incapable of philosophical utterance." Professor Robert Greenberg
of the San Francisco Conservatory of Music agrees, describes his turn
towards a troubled inner world where he, “found a world of
self-expression that he might never have discovered had he felt less
alienated from society.” In 1868,
at the age of 28, Tchaikovsky met the Belgian soprano Désirée
Artôt, then on a tour of Russia. They became infatuated, and were engaged to be married. He dedicated his Romance in F minor for piano, Op. 5, to her.
However, on September 15, 1869, without any communication with
Tchaikovsky, Artôt married a member of her company, the Spanish
baritone Mariano
Padilla
y Ramos. The general view has been that Tchaikovsky got
over the affair fairly quickly. It has, however, been postulated that
he coded her name into the Piano
Concerto
No. 1 in B-flat minor and
the
tone-poem Fatum. They
met
on a handful of later occasions, and in October 1888 he wrote Six French Songs,
Op. 65, for her, in response to her request for a single song.
Tchaikovsky later claimed she was the only woman he ever loved. In April
1877 Tchaikovsky's favorite pupil, Vladimir Shilovsky, married suddenly. Shilovsky's wedding may in
turn have spurred Tchaikovsky to consider such a step himself. He declared his intention
to marry in a letter to his brother. There
followed
Tchaikovsky's ill-starred marriage to one of his former
composition students, Antonina
Miliukova. The brief time with his wife drove him to an emotional
crisis, which was followed by a stay in Clarens,
Switzerland, for rest and recovery. They
remained
legally married but never lived together again nor had any
children, though she later gave birth to three children by another man. Tchaikovsky's
marital
debacle may have forced him to face the full truth concerning
his sexuality. He apparently never again
considered matrimony as a camouflage or escape, nor considered himself
capable of loving women in the same manner as men. He wrote to his brother
Anatoly from Florence, Italy on February 19, 1878, Thanks
to the regularity of my life, to the sometimes tedious but always
inviolable calm, and above all, thanks to time which heals all wounds,
I have completely recovered from my insanity.
There's
no doubt that for some months on end I was a bit insane, and only
now, when I'm completely recovered, have I learned to relate objectively to everything which I did
during my brief insanity. That man who in May took it into his head to
marry Antonina Ivanova, who during June wrote a whole opera as though
nothing had happened, who in July married, who in September fled from
his wife, who in November railed at Rome and so on — that man wasn't I,
but another Pyotr Ilyich. A few
days later, in another letter to Anatoly, he added that there was
"nothing more futile than wanting to be anything other than what I am
by nature." It
has
been commonly held that the strain of the marriage and Tchaikovsky's
emotional state immediately preceding it may have enhanced
Tchaikovsky's creativity. To some extent, this may have been the case.
While the Fourth
Symphony was begun
some months before Tchaikovsky married Antonina, both the symphony and the
opera Eugene
Onegin, arguably two of his finest compositions, are held up as proof of
this enhanced creativity. He finished both these
works in the six months between his engagement and the completion of
the rest cure following his marriage breakdown. While in Clarens he
also composed his Violin
Concerto, with the technical assistance of one of his former
students, violinist Yosif Kotek. Kotek later helped establish contact
between Tchaikovsky and Nadezhda von Meck, the widow of a railway
magnate, who became the composer's patron and confidante. Like the
First Piano Concerto, the Violin Concerto was rejected initially by its
intended dedicatee, virtuoso and pedagogue Leopold
Auer, and was premiered by Adolph
Brodsky. While the work eventually achieved public success, the
audience hissed at its premiere in Vienna, and it was denigrated by
music critic Eduard
Hanslick: The
Russian composer Tchaikovsky is surely no ordinary talent, but rather,
an inflated one, obsessed with posturing as a man of genius, and
lacking all discrimination and taste ... the same can be said for
his new, long, and ambitious Violin Concerto. For a while it proceeds
soberly, musically, and not mindlessly, but soon vulgarity gains the
upper hand and dominates until the end of the first movement. The
violin is no longer played: it is tugged about, torn, beaten black and
blue ... The Adagio is well on the way to reconciling us and winning us
over when, all too soon, it breaks off to make way for a finale that
transports us to the brutal and wretched jollity of a Russian church
festival. We see a host of gross and savage faces, hear crude curses,
and smell the booze. In the course of a discussion of obscener
illustrations, Friedrich
Vischer once
maintained that there were pictures whose stink one could see.
Tchaikovsky's Violin Concerto confronts us for the first time with the
hideous idea that there may be musical compositions whose stink one can
hear. Auer
belatedly accepted the concerto, and eventually played it to great
public success. In future years he taught the work to his pupils, including Jascha
Heifetz and Nathan
Milstein. Auer later said about Hanslick's comment that "the last
movement was redolent of vodka [...] did credit neither to his good
judgment nor to his reputation as a critic." The
intensity of personal emotion now flowing through Tchaikovsky's works
was entirely new to Russian music. It prompted some Russian commentators to place his name alongside that of novelist Fyodor
Dostoyevsky. Like Dostoyevsky's
characters, they felt the musical hero in Tchaikovsky's music persisted
in exploring the meaning of life while trapped in a fatal
love-death-faith triangle. The critic Osoovski wrote
of Tchaikovsky and Dostoyevsky: "With a hidden passion they both stop
at moments of horror, total spiritual collapse, and finding acute
sweetness in the cold trepidation of the heart before the abyss, they
both force the reader to experience those feelings, too." Tchaikovsky's
fame
among concert audiences began to expand outside Russia, and
continued to grow within it. Hans von Bülow had become a fervent
champion of the composer's work after hearing some of it in a Moscow
concert during Lent of 1874. In a German newspaper later
that year, he praised the First
String
Quartet, Romeo
and Juliet and
other works, and he later took up many other Tchaikovsky works both as
pianist and conductor. In France, Camille Benoit
began introducing Tchaikovsky's music to readers of the Revue et gazette
musicale de Paris. The music also received significant exposure
during the 1878 International Exhibition in Paris. While Tchaikovsky's
reputation as a composer grew, a corresponding increase in performances
of his works did not occur until he began conducting them himself,
starting in the mid 1880s. Nevertheless,
by
1880, all of the operas Tchaikovsky had completed up that point had
been staged, and his orchestral works had been given performances that
had been sympathetically received. Nadezhda
von Meck was the wealthy widow of a Russian railway tycoon and an
influential patron of the arts. Having already heard some of
Tchaikovsky's work, she was encouraged by Kotek to commission some
chamber pieces from him. Her support became an important element in Tchaikovsky's life; she eventually paid him an
annual subsidy of 6,000 rubles,
which
made it possible for him to resign from the Moscow Conservatory
in October 1878 at the age of 38, and concentrate on composition. With von Meck's patronage came a relationship that, at her insistence, was mainly epistolary –
she stipulated they were never to meet face to face. They exchanged
well over 1,000 letters between 1877 and 1890. In these letters
Tchaikovsky was more open about much of his life and his creative
processes than he had been to any other person. As well
as being a dedicated supporter of Tchaikovsky's musical works, Nadezhda
von Meck became a vital enabler in his day-to-day existence by her
financial support and friendship. As he explained to her, There
is something so special about our relationship that it often stops me
in my tracks with amazement. I have told you more than once, I believe,
that you have come to seem to me the hand of Fate itself, watching over
me and protecting me. The very fact that I do not know you personally,
while feeling so close to you, accords you in my eyes the special
status of an unseen but benevolent presence, like a benign Providence. In 1884
Tchaikovsky and von Meck became related by marriage when one of her
sons, Nikolay, married Tchaikovsky's niece Anna Davydova. However, in 1890 she
suddenly ended her relationship with the composer. She was suffering
from health problems that made writing difficult; there were family
pressures, and also financial difficulties arising from the
mismanagement of her estate by her son Vladimir. The break with Tchaikovsky
was announced in a letter delivered by a trusted servant, rather than
by the usual postal service. It contained a request that he not forget
her, and was accompanied by a year's subsidy in advance. She claimed
bankruptcy, which, if not literally true, was evidently a real threat
at the time. Tchaikovsky
may
have been aware for nearly a year of his patroness's financial
difficulties. This did not stop him from
continuing to take his allowance for granted (with regular
protestations of his eternal gratitude), nor did he offer to return the
advance he received with the farewell letter. Despite his growing
celebrity throughout Europe, von Meck's allowance still made up a third
of the composer's income. While he may have no longer
needed her money as much as in the past, the loss of her friendship and
encouragement was devastating; he remained bewildered and resentful
about her abrupt disappearance for the remaining three years of his
life. Tchaikovsky
returned
to Moscow Conservatory in the autumn of 1879, having been away
from Russia for a year after the disintegration of his marriage.
However, he quickly resigned, settling in Kamenka yet traveling
incessantly. During these years, assured of a regular income from Nadezhda von Meck, he wandered around Europe
and rural Russia, never staying long in any one place and living mainly
alone, avoiding social contact whenever possible. This may have been due in
part to troubles with Antonina, who alternately agreed to, then
refused, divorce, at one point exacerbating matters by moving into an
apartment directly above her husband's. Tchaikovsky listed
Antonina's accusations to him in detail to Modest: "I am a deceiver who
married her in order to hide my true nature ... I insulted her
every day, her sufferings at my hands were great ... she is
appalled by my shameful vice, etc., etc." It is possible that he lived
the rest of his life in dread of Antonina's power to expose publicly
his sexual leanings. These factors may explain why, except for the piano
trio which he wrote
upon the death of Nikolai Rubinstein, his best work from this period is
found in genres which did not depend heavily on personal expression. While
Tchaikovsky's reputation grew rapidly outside Russia, it was, as Alexandre
Benois wrote in his memoirs, "considered obligatory [in progressive
musical circles in Russia] to treat Tchaikovsky as a renegade, a master
overly dependent on the West." In 1880 this assessment
changed, practically overnight. During commemoration ceremonies for the
Pushkin Monument in Moscow, Dostoyevsky charged that Alexander
Pushkin had given a
prophetic call to Russia for "universal unity" with the West. An unprecedented acclaim
for Dostoyevsky's message spread throughout Russia, and disdain for
Tchaikovsky's music dissipated. He even drew a cult following among the
young intelligentsia of St. Petersburg,
including Benois, Léon
Bakst and Sergei
Diaghilev. In 1880
the Cathedral
of
Christ the Saviour, commissioned by Tsar Alexander
I to commemorate
the defeat of Napoleon in 1812, was nearing completion in Moscow; the
25th anniversary of the coronation of Alexander
II in 1881 was
imminent; and
the
1882 Moscow Arts and Industry Exhibition was in the planning stage.
Nikolai Rubinstein suggested a grand commemorative piece for use in
related festivities. Tchaikovsky began the project in October 1880,
finishing it within six weeks. He wrote to Nadezhda von Meck that the
resulting work, the 1812
Overture, would be "very loud and noisy, but I wrote it with no
warm feeling of love, and therefore there will probably be no artistic
merits in it." He also warned conductor Eduard
Nápravník that
"I
shan't be at all surprised and offended if you find that it is in a
style unsuitable for symphony concerts." Nevertheless, this work has
become for many, as Tchaikovsky authority Professor
David
Brown phrased
it, "the piece by Tchaikovsky they know best." On March
23, 1881, Nikolai Rubinstein died in Paris.
Tchaikovsky
was holidaying in Rome,
and
he went immediately to attend the funeral in Paris for his greatly
respected mentor, but arrived too late (although he was part of a group
of people who saw Rubinstein's coffin off on a train back to Russia). In December, he started
work on his Piano
Trio
in A minor, "dedicated to the memory of a great artist." The trio was first
performed privately at the Moscow Conservatory, where Rubinstein had
been director, on the first anniversary of his death by three of its
staff — pianist Sergei
Taneyev, violinist Jan
Hřímalý and
cellist Wilhelm
Fitzenhagen. The piece became extremely
popular during the composer's lifetime and, in an ironic twist of fate,
became Tchaikovsky's own elegy when played at memorial
concerts in Moscow and St. Petersburg in November 1893.
During
1884,
now 44 years old, Tchaikovsky began to shed his unsociability and
restlessness. In March of that year Tsar Alexander III conferred upon
him the Order
of
St. Vladimir (fourth
class),
which carried with it hereditary
nobility and won Tchaikovsky a
personal audience with the Tsar. The Tsar's decoration was a
visible seal of official approval, that helped Tchaikovsky's social
rehabilitation. This rehabilitation may
have been cemented in the composer's mind with the extreme success of his Third
Orchestral
Suite at
its January 1885 premiere in Saint Petersburg, under Hans
von
Bülow's direction. Tchaikovsky
wrote
to Nadezhda von Meck: "I have never seen such a triumph. I saw
the whole audience was moved, and grateful to me. These moments are the
finest adornments of an artist's life. Thanks to these it is worth
living and laboring." The
press
was likewise unanimously favorable. In 1885,
after Tchaikovsky resettled in Russia, the Tsar asked personally for a
new production of Eugene
Onegin to be
staged in Saint Petersburg. The opera had previously been seen only in
Moscow, produced by a student ensemble from the Conservatory. Though critical reception to the Saint Petersburg production of Onegin was negative, the opera
drew full houses every night; 15 years later the composer's brother
Modest identified this as the moment Tchaikovsky became known and
appreciated by the masses, and he achieved the greatest degree of
popularity ever accorded to a Russian composer. News of the opera's
success spread, and the work was produced by opera houses throughout
Russia and abroad. A feature
of the Saint Petersburg production of Onegin was that Alexander III
requested that the opera be staged not at the Mariyinsky
Theater but at the Bolshoi
Kamennïy
Theater. This served notice that Tchaikovsky's music
was replacing Italian
opera as the
official imperial art. In addition, thanks to Ivan Vsevolozhsky, Director of the Imperial Theaters and a patron of the
composer, Tchaikovsky was awarded a lifetime pension of 3,000 rubles
per year from the Tsar. This essentially made him the premier court
composer, in practice if not in actual title. While he
still felt a disdain for public life, Tchaikovsky now participated in
it for two reasons — his increasing celebrity and what he felt was his
duty to promote Russian music. To
this end, he helped
support his former pupil Taneyev, who was now director of Moscow
Conservatory, by attending student examinations and negotiating the
sometimes sensitive relations among various members of the staff. Tchaikovsky also served as
director of the Moscow branch of the Russian Musical Society during the
1889 - 1890 season. In this post, he invited a number of international
celebrities to conduct, including Johannes
Brahms, Antonín
Dvořák and Jules
Massenet. Another
area in which Tchaikovsky promoted Russian music in general as well as
his own compositions was as a guest conductor. In January 1887 he
substituted at the Bolshoi
Theater in Moscow
on short notice for the first three performances of his opera Cherevichki. He had wanted to conquer
conducting for at least a decade, as he saw that success outside Russia
depended to some extent on his conducting his own works. Within a year of the Cherevichki performances,
Tchaikovsky
was in considerable demand throughout Europe and Russia,
which helped him overcome a life-long stage
fright and boosted
his self-assurance. Conducting brought him to
America in 1891, where he led the New
York
Music Society's orchestra in his Festival Coronation March at the inaugural concert of New
York's Carnegie
Hall. In 1888
Tchaikovsky led the premiere of his Fifth
Symphony in Saint
Petersburg, repeating the work a week later with the first performance of his tone poem Hamlet.
While
both works were received with extreme enthusiasm by audiences,
critics proved hostile, with César
Cui calling the
symphony "routine" and "meretricious." Undeterred, Tchaikovsky
continued to conduct the symphony in Russia and Europe. In
November 1887, Tchaikovsky arrived in Saint Petersburg in time to hear
several of the Russian
Symphony
Concerts, which were devoted exclusively to the music of
Russian composers. One of these concerts included the first complete
performance of the final version of his First
Symphony; another featured the premiere of the revised version of
Rimsky-Korsakov's Third Symphony. Before this visit
Tchaikovsky had spent much time keeping in touch with Rimsky-Korsakov
and those around him. Rimsky-Korsakov, along with Alexander
Glazunov, Anatoly
Lyadov and several
other nationalistically minded composers and musicians, had formed a
group called the Belyayev
circle. This group was named after timber merchant Mitrofan
Belyayev, an amateur musician who became a influential music patron
and publisher after he had taken an interest in Glazunov's work. (Belyayev
also
funded the Russian Symphony Concerts as a forum for native
composers to have their works heard in public.) During Tchaikovsky's visit,
he spent much time in the company of Glazunov, Lyadov and
Rimsky-Korsakov, and the somewhat fraught relationship he had endured
with the Belyayev circle's predecessor, The Five, melded into something
more harmonious. This relationship lasted until Tchaikovsky's death in
late 1893. A side
benefit of Tchaikovsky's friendship with Glazunov, Lyadov and
Rimsky-Korsakov was an increased confidence in his own abilities as a
composer, along with a willingness to let his musical works stand
alongside those of his contemporaries. Tchaikovsky wrote to Nadezhda
von Meck in January 1889, after being once again well-represented in
Belyayev's concerts, that he had "always tried to place myself outside all
parties and to show in
every way possible that I love and respect every honorable and gifted
public figure in music, whatever his tendency", and that he considered
himself "flattered to appear on the concert platform" beside composers
in the Belyayev circle. This was an acknowledgment
of wholehearted readiness for his music to be heard with that of these
composers, delivered in a tone of implicit confidence that there were
no comparisons from which to fear. In 1892,
Tchaikovsky was voted a member of the Académie
des
Beaux-Arts in
France; he was only the second Russian, after the sculptor Mark
Antokolsky, to be so honored. The following year, the University
of
Cambridge in
Britain awarded Tchaikovsky an honorary Doctor
of
Music degree. Tchaikovsky
died
in Saint Petersburg on November 6, 1893, nine days after the
premiere of his Sixth
Symphony, the Pathétique. Though only 53 years old, he
lived a long life compared to many 19th century composers. He was
interred in Tikhvin
Cemetery at the Alexander Nevsky Monastery, near the graves of fellow composers Alexander
Borodin, Mikhail
Glinka, Nikolai
Rimsky-Korsakov, Mily Balakirev and Modest
Mussorgsky. Because of the Pathétique's formal innovation and the
overwhelming emotional content of its outer movements, the work was
received by the public with silent incomprehension at its first
performance. The second performance, led
by Nápravník, took place 20 days later at a memorial
concert and was much more favorably
received. The Pathétique has since become one of
Tchaikovsky's best known works. Tchaikovsky's
death
has traditionally been attributed to cholera,
most
probably contracted through drinking contaminated water several days earlier. However, some, including
English musicologist and Tchaikovsky authority David
Brown and biographer Anthony
Holden,
have theorized that his death was a suicide. According to
one variation of the theory, a sentence of suicide was imposed in a
"court of honor" by Tchaikovsky's fellow alumni of the St. Petersburg
Imperial School of Jurisprudence, as a censure of the composer's
homosexuality. This unproven theory was first broached publicly by
Russian musicologist Alexandra Orlova in 1979, when she emigrated to
the West. Wiley writes in the New Grove (2001), "The polemics over
[Tchaikovsky's] death have reached an impasse ... Rumor attached to the
famous die hard ... As for illness, problems of evidence offer little
hope of satisfactory resolution: the state of diagnosis; the confusion
of witnesses; disregard of long-term effects of smoking and alcohol. We
do not know how Tchaikovsky died. We may never find out ..." |