January 17, 2012 <Back to Index>
PAGE SPONSOR |
Charles Brockden Brown (January 17, 1771 – February 22, 1810), an American novelist,historian, and editor of the Early National period, is generally regarded by scholars as the most ambitious and accomplished US novelist before James Fenimore Cooper. He is the most frequently studied and republished practitioner of the "early American novel," or the US novel between 1789 and roughly 1820. Although Brown was by no means the first American novelist, as some early criticism claimed, the breadth and complexity of his achievement as a writer in multiple genres (novels, short stories, essays and periodical writings of every sort, poetry, historiography, reviews) makes him a crucial figure in US literature and culture of the 1790s and first decade of the 19th century, and a significant public intellectual in the wider Atlantic print culture and public sphere of the era of the French Revolution. Brown was born on January 17, 1771, the fourth of five brothers and seven surviving siblings total in a Philadelphia Quaker merchant family. His father Elijah Brown, originally from Chester County, Pennsylvania, just southwest of Philadelphia, had a variable career primarily as a land-conveyancer or agent in real estate transactions. The two oldest brothers, Joseph and James, and youngest brother Elijah, Jr., were import - export merchants and bought shares in re-export ventures as early as the 1780s. Brown became a reluctant partner of their short lived family re-export firm, James Brown & Co., from late 1800 to the firm's dissolution during 1806. The third brother, Armitt, was a clerk for the Treasury department and at the Bank of Pennsylvania (for a time Armitt was a clerk with Alexander Hamilton). The family's mercantile background and experiences in the global trade and trade conflicts of the revolutionary era are relevant to Brown's writings insofar as he often explores issues connected to the period's culture of commerce and the role that commerce plays in the historical transition from 18th century civic republicanism to 19th century laissez faire liberalism, capitalism, and imperialism. Brown's family intended for him to become a lawyer. After six years in Philadelphia at the law office of Alexander Wilcocks, he ended his law studies during 1793. He became part of a group of young, New York based intellectuals who helped begin his literary career. The New York group included a number of young male professionals who called themselves the Friendly Club (including Dr. Elihu Hubbard Smith, Brown's closest friend during this period, and William Dunlap), along with female friends and relatives who were interested in companionship and cultural - political conversation. During
most of the 1790s, Brown developed his literary ambitions in projects
that often remained incomplete (for example the so-called "Henrietta
Letters," transcribed in the Clark biography) and frequently used his
correspondence with friends as a sort of laboratory for narrative
experiments. His first publications appeared during the late 1780s
(e.g. "The Rhapsodist" essay series from 1789), but generally he
published little during this period. By 1798, however, these formative
years gave way to a period of novel writing during which Brown
published the titles for which he is best known. In complex ways, these
novels and the rest of Brown's career are informed by the progressive
ideas he uses and develops from the period's British radical -
democratic
writers, most notably Mary Wollstonecraft, William Godwin, Thomas Holcroft, and Robert Bage.
Brown was influenced by these writers and in turn exerted an influence
on them and their younger studiers, for example in Godwin's later
novels, or in the work of Percy Bysshe Shelley and Mary Shelley, who reread Brown as she wrote her novels Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus (1818) and The Last Man (1826). During the novelistic phase that lasts from 1798 until late 1801, Brown published the Wollstonecraftian - feminist dialog Alcuin (1798),
and seven subsequent novels. An additional novel was written, but was
lost by a series of mishaps and consequently never saw publication. In
addition to his output of novels, Brown also became an editor during
this period and, along with his friends in New York published and wrote
many short articles and reviews for The Monthly Magazine and American Review from April 1799 to December 1800, as well as its short lived successor, The American Review and Literary Journal (1801 – 1802). Finally, besides these two New York periodicals, Brown also published numerous fictional pieces, including the only surviving fragment of his first novel Sky-Walk, in the Philadelphia based Weekly Magazine of Original Essays, Fugitive Pieces, and Interesting Intelligence (1798 – 1799). Brown's novels are often characterized simply as gothic fiction, although the model he develops is far from the Gothic romance mode of writers such as Ann Radcliffe.
Brown's novels combine several revolutionary era fiction subgenres with
other types of late Enlightenment scientific and medical knowledges.
Most notably, they develop the British radical - democratic models of
Wollstonecraft, Godwin, and Holcroft and combine these with elements of
German "Schauer-romantik" gothic from Friedrich Schiller, the enlightened sentimental fictions of Jean-Jacques Rousseau or Laurence Sterne, women's domestic novels by writers such as Fanny Burney or Hannah Webster Foster, and other genres such as captivity narrative. Brown builds plots around particular motifs such as sleepwalking and religious mania, drawing on Enlightenment era medical writings by people such as Erasmus Darwin. Of the seven novels extant, the first four to be published in book form (Wieland, Ormond, Edgar Huntly, and Arthur Mervyn) have received the lion's share of commentary and
attention. Because of their sensational violence, dramatic intensity,
and intellectual complexity, these four novels are often referred to as
the "gothic" or "Godwinian" novels. Stephen Calvert, which appeared only in serialized form and in the posthumous 1815 biography, remained little read until the end of the 20th century, but is notable as the first US novel to thematize same sex sexuality. Clara Howard and Jane Talbot have been regarded sometimes as relatively conventional works distinct from the earlier novels because they have classic epistolary form
and concern domestic issues that seem very different from the violence
and sensationalism of the first four novels. Recent scholarship (since
the 1980s), however, has largely revised this view and emphasizes the
continuities and overall coherence of all seven novels understood as a
loosely unified ensemble. Brown
articulates a well defined technique and plan for his novel writing in
essays such as "Walstein's School of History" (1799) and "The
Difference Between History and Romance" (1800). In these essays, he
explains that his novels combine fiction and history to place ordinary
individuals (like his novelistic protagonists Arthur Mervyn or Edgar Huntly) into situations of historical stress (like the Yellow Fever epidemic of 1793 or settler - Indian violence on the Pennsylvania frontier after the Walking Purchase)
in such a way as to educate his audience about virtuous behaviors and the
historical causes and conditions of individual actions. In short, Brown
uses his Wollstonecraftian - Godwinian models to develop political
fiction that is intended to educate his readers and to be part in the
ideological and cultural debates of his period. Brown's life long
support for feminism, for example, originates both from his Quaker
background, and from his commitment to the late Enlightenment ideals of
the revolutionary era. While
crucial aspects of Brown's overall orientation and novelistic method
are adapted from the British Wollstonecraftian - Godwinian writers, it is
important to note that he was no mere imitator of his sources, but an
independent thinker who advanced and refined their ideas and techniques
as he adopted them. Brown shares with the British radical - democrats an
emphasis on sociocultural determinism and on the use of literature as a
medium for spreading progressive ideas. In addition, he shares with
Godwin, in particular, the project of combining historical and
fictional modes into a distinctive and progressive narrative style
designed to stimulate social awareness and action. But he advances
their models, for example, by placing a new emphasis on the culture and
contradictions of economic liberalism and the world of commerce,
focusing on a crucial topic that his British novelistic sources
minimized, but which would grow exponentially in importance throughout
the post-revolutionary era. It is also significant that Brown examines
issues associated with personal identity (race, gender and sexuality, etc.)
in ways that the British radical - democratic novelists did not,
primarily by associating them with larger issues of social and economic
power in the new liberal order that was emerging at the turn of the
19th century. As Brown indicates in the "Walstein's School of History"
essay, two primary topics of drama of his novelistic plots are "sex"
(or gender relations) and "property" (or economic relations). After 1801 Brown continued to publish prolifically. He authored several important political pamphlets arguing for the acquisition of the Louisiana Territory and against the Embargo Act of 1807. He edited and was primary contributor to two more magazines: The Literary Magazine and American Register (1803 – 1806), a miscellany on cultural and other topics (from geography and medicine to history and aesthetics) and The American Register and General Repository of History, Politics, and Science (1807 – 09).
The latter is notable for the book length "Annals of Europe and
America," Brown's contemporary historical narrative of Napoleonic geopolitics. Brown continued to write fiction and experiment with other literary genres during this period, notably in the Historical Sketches, a group of historical fictions that were written between 1803 and 1807 but published only posthumously.
These late experimental narratives show Brown exploring the interface
of fiction and history at the end of the revolutionary era, at a moment
that both follows the great Enlightenment historians (e.g., David Hume, William Robertson, Edward Gibbon) and prefigures the emergence of the 19th century historical romance form in writers like Walter Scott or James Fenimore Cooper. He also published miscellaneous pieces in other Philadelphia newspapers and magazines of the 19th century including the Aurora and, in 1809, the Port-Folio. In addition to these pamphlets, magazines, and historical narratives, it is notable that Brown maintained his contacts with reformist and
progressive individuals and institutions in 19th century Philadelphia.
Although it was never completed, Brown planned from 1803 to 1806, with
close friend Thomas Pym Cope, to publish a "History of Slavery" using
the records of the Pennsylvania Abolition Society. Benjamin Rush recommended Brown in 1803 as an ideal author for a history of penal reform
in Philadelphia. Brown maintained a well informed interest in these
sorts of reformist institutions and since the early 1790s had regularly
visited new, pioneering hospitals and prisons (such as Philadelphia's Walnut Street Prison or Pennsylvania Hospital)
with friends from his New York circle. In addition, he contracted to
publish a major introduction to Geography during his last years, but the manuscript is
now lost. Politically, Brown has been an enigma, but more recent
scholarship considers Brown as having, for instance, few or no
associations with a Federalist political agenda and instead divorcing
himself from the ideology of America as an exemplary nation, and
desiring "political justice" on both sides of the Atlantic. Brown died of tuberculosis in Philadelphia on February 22, 1810, at the age of 39. Although
Brown's writings did not achieve immediate commercial success, he was
republished in both the U.S. and England throughout the romantic era
and developed a widespread and influential reputation as a "writer's
writer." New editions of his works were published and reviewed widely
in North America and England during the 1820s, for example, when
Brown's novels were also published in combined editions with those of
Schiller and Mary Shelley. His novels were the first U.S. novels
translated into other European languages: Ormond was published in German (where it was attributed to Godwin) during 1803, and a French version of Wieland appeared in 1808. An abridged version of William Dunlap's posthumous 1815 biography of him was also reprinted in England during
1822. The most important group of writers influenced by Brown during
this period was the Godwin - Shelley circle mentioned above, but Brown
was read and recommended by many other major British writers of this
era, notably William Hazlitt, Thomas Love Peacock, John Keats, and Walter Scott. Among US writers, Margaret Fuller, Edgar Allan Poe, Nathaniel Hawthorne, Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, and John Greenleaf Whittier were notable in regarding Brown as a particularly influential and significant predecessor. Philadelphia novelist and journalist George Lippard included a dedication to Brown in his 1845 bestseller The Quaker City; or, The Monks of Monk Hall. Brown
was less widely read at the end of the 19th century, when prevailing
Realist and Naturalist literary styles obscured most fiction of Brown's
era. Literary - critical scholarship revived interest when American Studies scholars like Vernon Louis Parrington and
Fred Lewis Pattee examined his works in the 1920s and subsequent
decades. Between the 1950s and the 1970s, scholarly biographies and monographs began to appear on Brown. Major scholars such as Leslie Fiedler, who discussed Brown in his landmark study Love and Death in the American Novel (1960),
helped repopularize his work, although scholarly emphasis in the mid
and late 20th century emphasized Brown's novels, largely ignoring his
voluminous periodical writings, pamphlets, and historical narratives. The
contemporary era of interest in Brown begins with the publication of a
modern scholarly edition of Brown's novels, the six volume Kent State "Bicentennial
Edition" that was organized by Sidney J. Krause and S.W. Reid and
appeared from 1977 to 1987. During the same period, new but still
incomplete attempts to publish a selection of non-novelistic writings
were initiated by German scholar Alfred Weber. Since the 1980s, new
scholarship on both Brown and the early national period, accompanied by
new mass market editions of Brown's novels and increasing efforts to
understand Brown's entire career, has transformed the understanding of
Brown's writing and its place in US cultural history. Brown was
regarded as a somewhat secondary novelist by scholars in the cold war era who focused on normative aesthetic
criteria and tended to ignore the wide scope of his writings, but more
recent and historically oriented scholarship has reestablished Brown as
a leading writer and intellectual of the late enlightenment and early republic.
At the beginning of the 21st century, Brown is widely acknowledged as a
key figure in US literary history whose writings provide insight into
the major ideological, intellectual, and artistic struggles and
transformations of the Atlantic revolutionary era. A Charles Brockden
Brown Society, founded during 2000, has regular conferences on the work
of Brown and his contemporaries. In 2009, The Library of America selected
Brown’s essay “Somnambulism: A Fragment” for inclusion in its
two century retrospective of American Fantastic Tales, edited by Peter Straub. |