April 25, 2013 <Back to Index>
PAGE SPONSOR |
Edward II (25 April 1284 – 1327(?)), called Edward of Caernarfon, was King of England from 1307 until he was deposed by his wife Isabella in January 1327. He was the sixth Plantagenet king, in a line that began with the reign of Henry II. Interspersed between the strong reigns of his father Edward I and son Edward III, the reign of Edward II was disastrous for England, marked by incompetence, political squabbling and military defeats. Widely rumoured to have been either homosexual or bisexual, Edward fathered at least five children by two women. His inability to deny even the most grandiose favours to his male favourites (first a Gascon knight named Piers Gaveston, later a young English lord named Hugh Despenser) led to constant political unrest and his eventual deposition. The behavior resulted in contemporary accusations of sodomy from Bishop Adam Orleton of Hereford, an ally of Roger Mortimer and Queen Isabella in their successful insurgency against Edward. Edward I had pacified Gwynedd and some other parts of Wales and the Scottish lowlands, but never exerted a comprehensive conquest. However the army of Edward II was devastatingly defeated at Bannockburn, freeing Scotland from English control and allowing Scottish forces to raid unchecked throughout the north of England. In addition to these disasters, Edward II is remembered for his probable death in Berkeley Castle, allegedly by murder, and for being the first monarch to establish colleges at Oxford and Cambridge, Oriel College and King's Hall, a predecessor of Trinity College, at Cambridge, respectively.
The fourth son of Edward I by his first wife Eleanor of Castile, Edward II was born at Caernarfon Castle. He was the first English prince to hold the title Prince of Wales, which was formalised by the Parliament of Lincoln of 7 February 1301. The story that his father presented Edward II as a newborn to the Welsh as
their future native prince did not appear until the 16th century. The
Welsh purportedly asked the King to give them a prince who spoke Welsh, and, the story goes, he answered he would give them a prince that spoke no English at all. This was no great concession as the Plantagenets spoke Norman French rather than English. Edward became heir apparent at just a few months of age, following the death of his elder brother Alphonso. His father, a notable military leader, trained his heir in warfare and statecraft starting in his childhood, yet the young Edward preferred boating and craftwork, activities considered beneath kings at the time. The prince took part in several Scots campaigns,
but despite these martial engagements, "all his father's efforts could
not prevent his acquiring the habits of extravagance and frivolity
which he retained all through his life". The king attributed his son’s preferences to his strong attachment to Piers Gaveston, a Gascon knight, and Edward I exiled Gaveston from court after Prince Edward attempted to bestow on his friend a
title reserved for royalty. Ironically, it was the king who had
originally chosen Gaveston in 1298 to be a suitable friend for his son
due to his wit, courtesy and abilities. Edward
I knighted his son in a major ceremony in 1306 called the Feast of the
Swans whereby all present swore to continue the war in Scotland.
Edward
I died on 7 July 1307 en route to another campaign against the Scots, a
war that had become the hallmark of his reign. One chronicler relates
that Edward had requested his son "boil his body, extract the bones and
carry them with the army until the Scots had been subdued." His son
ignored the request, however, and had his father buried in Westminster Abbey. Edward II immediately recalled Gaveston, created him Earl of Cornwall, gave him the hand of the king's niece, Margaret of Gloucester, and withdrew from the Scottish campaign. Edward
was as physically impressive as his father, yet he lacked the drive and
ambition of his forebear. It was written that Edward II was "the first
king after the Conquest who was not a man of business". His main interest was in entertainment, though he also took pleasure in athletics and
mechanical crafts. He had been so dominated by his father that he had
little confidence in himself, and was often in the hands of a court
favourite with a stronger will than his own. On 25 January 1308, Edward married Isabella of France, the daughter of King Philip IV of France, known as "Philip the Fair," and sister to three French kings, in an attempt to bolster an alliance with France. On 25 February the pair were crowned in Westminster Abbey. The
marriage, however, was doomed to failure almost from the beginning.
Isabella was frequently neglected by her husband, who spent much of his
time conspiring with his favourites regarding how to limit the powers
of the Peerage in order to consolidate his father's legacy for himself. Nevertheless, their marriage produced two sons, Edward, who would succeed his father on the throne as Edward III, and John of Eltham (later created Earl of Cornwall), and two daughters, Eleanor and Joanna, wife of David II of Scotland. Edward had also fathered at least one illegitimate son, Adam FitzRoy, who accompanied his father in the Scottish campaigns of 1322 and died shortly afterwards. In 1308 Edward travelled to Boulogne to
marry Isabella, leaving Gaveston to act as regent. It was here that the
first discontent with the new king's rule found expression, through the
so-called Boulogne agreement. As
the resentment against Edward's rule and Gaveston's position of power
grew, some barons began to insist Gaveston be banished, through the Ordinances of 1311. Edward recalled his friend, but could do little to prevent Gaveston being captured in 1312 under the orders of the Earl of Lancaster and
his allies, who claimed that he had led the king to folly. He was
captured first by the Earl of Warwick, whom he was seen to have
offended, and handed over to two Welshmen. They took him to Blacklow
Hill and murdered him; one ran him through the heart with his sword and
the other beheaded him. A monument called Gaveston's Cross remains on
the site, south of Leek Wootton near Warwick. Edward's
grief over the death of Gaveston was profound. He kept the remains of
his body close to him for a number of weeks before the Church forcibly
arranged a burial. Immediately following this, Edward focused on the
destruction of those who had betrayed him, while the barons themselves
lost impetus (with Gaveston dead, they saw little need to continue). By
mid July, Aymer de Valence, 2nd Earl of Pembroke was
advising the king to make war on the barons who, unwilling to risk
their lives, entered negotiations in September 1312. In October, the
Earls of Lancaster, Warwick, Arundel and Hereford were forced to beg
Edward's pardon. Several contemporary sources criticised Edward's seeming infatuation with Piers Gaveston, to the extent that he ignored and humiliated his wife. Chroniclers called the relationship excessive, immoderate, beyond measure and reason and criticised his desire for wicked and forbidden sex. The
Westminster chronicler claimed that Gaveston had led Edward to reject
the sweet embraces of his wife; while the Meaux Chronicle (written
several decades later) took concern further and complained that, Edward took too much delight in sodomy.
While such sources do not, in themselves, prove that Edward and
Gaveston were lovers, they at least show that some contemporaries and
later writers thought strongly that this might be the case. Gaveston was considered to be athletic and handsome; he was a few years older than Edward and had seen military service in Flanders before
becoming Edward's close companion. He was known to have a quick, biting
wit, and his fortunes continued to ascend as Edward obtained more
honours for him, including the Earldom of Cornwall. Earlier, Edward I had
attempted to control the situation by exiling Gaveston from England.
However, upon the elder king's death in 1307, Edward II immediately
recalled him. Isabella's marriage to Edward subsequently took place in
1308. Almost immediately, she wrote to her father, Philip the Fair, complaining of Edward's behaviour. Although
the relationship that developed between the two young men was certainly
very close, its exact nature is impossible to determine. The
relationship may have had a sexual element, though the evidence for
this is not conclusive. Both Edward and Gaveston married early in the
reign. There were children from both marriages - Edward also had an
illegitimate son, Adam. While some of the chroniclers' remarks can be
interpreted simply as homosexuality or bisexuality,
too many of them are either much later in date or the product of
hostility. It has also been plausibly argued that the two men may have
entered into a bond of adoptive brotherhood. British historian Ian Mortimer has drawn attention to the use of 'anti - sodomite' smear campaigns in the late 13th and early 14th centuries against Pope Boniface VIII and the Knights Templar. In the latter case, Orleton was a protagonist at the Papal Court at Avignon. The relationship was later explored in a play by the 16th century dramatist Christopher Marlowe. This is unusual in making explicit reference to an open sexual relationship
between king and favourite. More frequently the nature of the
relationship between the two is only hinted at, or is cited as a
dreadful example of the fate that may befall kings who allow themselves
to be influenced by favourites, and so become estranged from their
subjects.
Robert the Bruce had been steadily reconquering Scotland.
Each campaign begun by Edward, from 1307 to 1314, had ended in Robert
clawing back more of the land that Edward I had taken during his long
reign. Robert's military successes against Edward II were due to a
number of factors, not the least of which was the Scottish king's
strategy. He used small forces to trap an invading English army, took
castles by stealth to preserve his troops and he used the land as a
weapon against Edward by attacking quickly and then disappearing into
the hills instead of facing the superior numbers of the English. Bruce
united Scotland against its common enemy and is quoted as saying that
he feared more the dead king's bones (Edward I) than his living heir
(Edward II). By June 1314, only Stirling Castle and Berwick remained under English control. On
23 June 1314, Edward and an army of 20,000 foot soldiers and 3,000
cavalry faced Robert and his army of foot soldiers and farmers wielding
14 foot long pikes. Edward knew he had to keep the critical stronghold
of Stirling Castle if there was to be any chance for English military
success. The castle, however, was under a constant state of siege, and
the English commander, Sir Phillip de Mowbray, had advised Edward that
he would surrender the castle to the Scots unless Edward arrived by 24
June 1314, to relieve the siege. Edward could not afford to lose his
last forward castle in Scotland. He decided therefore to gamble his
entire army to break the siege and force the Scots to a final battle by
putting its army into the field. However,
Edward had made a serious mistake in thinking his vastly superior
numbers alone would provide enough of a tactical advantage to defeat
the Scots. Robert not only had the advantage of prior warning, as he
knew the actual day that Edward would come north and fight, he also had
the time to choose the field of battle most advantageous to the Scots
and their style of combat. As
Edward moved forward on the main road to Stirling, Robert placed his
army on either side of the road north, one in the dense woods and the
other placed on a bend on the river, a spot hard for the invading army
to see. Robert also ordered his men to dig potholes and cover them with
bracken in order to help break any cavalry charge. By
contrast, Edward did not issue his writs of service, calling upon
21,540 men, until 27 May 1314. Worse, his army was ill disciplined and
had seen little success in eight years of campaigns. On the eve of
battle, he decided to move his entire army at night and placed it in a
marshy area, with its cavalry laid out in nine squadrons in front of
the foot soldiers. The following battle, the Battle of Bannockburn, is considered by contemporary scholars to be the worst defeat sustained by the English since the Battle of Hastings in 1066. Following
Gaveston's death, the king increased favour to his nephew - by -
marriage (who was also Gaveston's brother - in - law), Hugh Despenser the Younger.
But, as with Gaveston, the barons were indignant at the privileges
Edward lavished upon the Despenser father and son, especially when the
younger Despenser began in 1318 to strive to procure for himself the
earldom of Gloucester and its associated lands. By 1320, the situation in England was again becoming dangerously unstable. Edward had been challenged by John Deydras,
a royal pretender; although Deydras was ultimately executed, the
rumours surrounding the case highlighted Edward's unpopularity. Edward ignored the law in favour of Despenser: when Lord de Braose of Gower
sold his title to his son - in - law, an action entirely lawful in the
Welsh Marches, Despenser demanded the king grant Gower to him instead.
The king, against all laws, then confiscated Gower from the purchaser
and offered it to Despenser; in so doing, he provoked the fury of most
of the barons. In 1321, the Earl of Hereford, along with the Earl of Lancaster and others, took up arms against the Despenser family, and the King was forced into an agreement with the barons. On 14 August at Westminster Hall, accompanied by the Earls of Pembroke and Richmond, the king declared the Despenser father and son both banished. The
victory of the barons proved their undoing. With the removal of the
Despensers, many nobles, regardless of previous affiliation, now
attempted to move into the vacuum left by the two. Hoping to win
Edward's favour, these nobles were willing to aid the king in his
revenge against the barons and thus increase their own wealth and
power. In following campaigns, many of the king's opponents were
murdered, the Earl of Lancaster being beheaded in the presence of
Edward himself. With all opposition crushed, the king and the Despensers were left the unquestioned masters of England. At the York Parliament of 1322, Edward issued a statute which revoked all previous ordinances
designed to limit his power and to prevent any further encroachment upon it. The king would no longer be subject to the will of Parliament,
and the Lords, Prelates, and Commons were to suffer his will in
silence. Opposition to Edward and the Despensers rule continued; in
1324 there was a foiled assassination attempt on their lives, and in
early 1325 John of Nottingham was placed on trial for involvement in a plot to kill them with magic.
A dispute between France and England then broke out over Edward's refusal to pay homage to the French king for the territory of
Gascony. After several bungled attempts to regain the territory, Edward sent his
wife, Isabella, to negotiate peace terms. Overjoyed, Isabella arrived
in France in March 1325. She was now able to visit her family and
native land as well as escape the Despensers and the king, all of whom
she now detested. On 31 May 1325, Isabella agreed to a peace treaty favouring France and requiring Edward to pay homage in France to her brother, King Charles;
but Edward decided instead to send his son to pay homage. This proved a
gross tactical error, and helped to bring about the ruin of both Edward
and the Despensers, as Isabella, now that she had her son with her,
declared that she would not return to England until Despenser was
removed.
When
Isabella's retinue — loyal to Edward, and ordered back to England by
Isabella — returned to the English Court on 23 December, they brought
further shocking news for the king: Isabella had formed a liaison with Roger Mortimer in Paris and they were now plotting an invasion of England. Edward
prepared for the invasion but was betrayed by those close to him: his
son refused to leave his mother, claiming he wanted to remain with her
during her unease and unhappiness. Edward's half - brother, the Earl of
Kent, married Mortimer's cousin, Margaret Wake; other nobles, such as
John de Cromwell and the Earl of Richmond, also chose to remain with
Mortimer. In
September 1326, Mortimer and Isabella invaded England. Edward was
amazed by their small numbers of soldiers, and immediately attempted to
levy an immense army to crush them. However, a large number of men
refused to fight Mortimer and the Queen; Henry of Lancaster, for
example, was not even summoned by the king, and he showed his loyalties
by raising an army, seizing a cache of Despenser treasure from Leicester Abbey, and marching south to join Mortimer. The
invasion soon had too much force and support to be stemmed. As a
result, the army the king had ordered failed to emerge and both Edward
and the Despensers were left isolated. They abandoned London on 2
October, leaving the city to fall into disorder. On
15 October a London mob seized and beheaded without trial John le
Marshal (a Londoner accused of being a spy for the Despensers) and
Edward II's Treasurer, Walter de Stapledon Bishop of Exeter, together with two of the bishop's squires. The king first took refuge in Gloucester (where he arrived on 9 October) and then fled to South Wales in order to make a defence in Despenser's lands. However,
Edward was unable to rally an army, and on 31 October, he was abandoned
by his servants, leaving him with only the younger Despenser and a few
retainers. On
27 October, the elder Despenser was accused of encouraging the illegal
government of his son, enriching himself at the expense of others,
despoiling the Church, and taking part in the illegal execution of the
Earl of Lancaster. He was hanged and
beheaded at the Bristol Gallows. Henry of Lancaster was then sent to
Wales in order to fetch the King and the younger Despenser; on 16
November he with Welsh rebels caught Edward, Despenser and their
soldiers in the open country near Tonyrefail, where a plaque now commemorates the event. Edward Longshanks' so-called
conquest of Wales with his Welsh allies had been short lived, the armed
Welsh were in permanent rebellion and Wales was in turmoil throughout
the 14th century. He and the soldiers were released and Despenser was
sent to Isabella at Hereford whilst the king was taken by Lancaster
himself to Kenilworth. Reprisals against Edward's allies began immediately thereafter. The Earl of Arundel, Sir Edmund Fitz Alan,
an old enemy of Roger Mortimer, was beheaded on 17 November, together
with two of the earl's retainers, John Daniel and Thomas de
Micheldever. This was followed by the trial and execution of Despenser
on 24 November. Hugh
Despenser the Younger was brutally executed and a huge crowd gathered
in anticipation at seeing him die — a public spectacle for public
entertainment. They dragged him from his horse, stripped him, and
scrawled Biblical verses against corruption and arrogance on his skin.
They then dragged him into the city, presenting him (in the market
square) to Queen Isabella, Roger Mortimer, and the Lancastrians. He was
then condemned to hang as a thief, be castrated, and then to be drawn and quartered as
a traitor, his quarters to be dispersed throughout England. Despenser's
vassal Simon of Reading was also hanged next to him, on charges of
insulting Queen Isabella. Edward II's Chancellor, Robert Baldock, was placed under house arrest in London, but a London mob broke into the house, severely beat him, and threw him into Newgate Prison, where he was murdered by some of the inmates.
With
the King imprisoned, Mortimer and the Queen faced the problem of what
to do with him. The simplest solution would be execution: his titles
would then pass to Edward of Windsor, whom Isabella could control,
while it would also prevent the possibility of his being restored.
Execution
would require the King to be tried and convicted of treason: and while
most Lords agreed that Edward had failed to show due attention to his
country, several Prelates argued that, appointed by God, the King could
not be legally deposed or executed; if this happened, they said, God
would punish the country. Thus, at first, it was decided to have Edward
imprisoned for life instead.
However, the fact remained that the legality of power still lay with
the King. Isabella had been given the
Great Seal,
and was using it to rule in the names of the King, herself, and their
son as appropriate; nonetheless, these actions were illegal, and could
at any moment be challenged. In these circumstances, Parliament chose to act as an authority above the King. Representatives of the House of Commons were summoned, and debates began. The Archbishop of York, William Melton and
others declared themselves fearful of the London mob, loyal to Roger
Mortimer. Others wanted the King to speak in Parliament and openly abdicate, rather than be deposed by the Queen and her General. Mortimer responded by commanding the Lord Mayor of London,
Richard de Betoyne, to write to Parliament, asking them to go to the
Guildhall to swear an oath to protect the Queen and Prince Edward, and
to depose the King. Mortimer then called the great lords to a secret
meeting that night, at which they gave their unanimous support to the
deposition of the King. Eventually
Parliament agreed to remove the King. However, for all that Parliament
had agreed that the King should no longer rule, they had not deposed
him. Rather, their decision made, Edward was asked to accept it. On 20 January 1327, Edward II was informed at Kenilworth Castle of
the charges brought against him: The King was guilty of incompetence;
allowing others to govern him to the detriment of the people and
Church; not listening to good advice and pursuing occupations
unbecoming to a monarch; having lost Scotland and lands in Gascony and Ireland through failure of effective governance; damaging the Church,
and imprisoning its representatives; allowing nobles to be killed,
disinherited, imprisoned and exiled; failing to ensure fair justice,
instead governing for profit and allowing others to do likewise; and of
fleeing in the company of a notorious enemy of the realm, leaving it
without government, and thereby losing the faith and trust of his
people. Edward,
profoundly shocked by this judgment, wept while listening. He was then
offered a choice: he might abdicate in favour of his son; or he might
resist, and relinquish the throne to one not of royal blood, but
experienced in government — this, presumably, being Roger Mortimer. The
King, lamenting that his people had so hated his rule, agreed that if
the people would accept his son, he would abdicate in his favour. The
lords, through the person of Sir William Trussell, then renounced their
homage to him, and the reign of Edward II ended. The
abdication was announced and recorded in London on 24 January 1327, and
the following day was proclaimed the first of the reign of Edward III — who, at 14, was still controlled by Isabella and Mortimer. Edward II remained imprisoned. A poem, the "Lament of Edward II", traditionally credited to Edward, may have been written during his imprisonment.
The
government of Isabella and Mortimer was so precarious that they dared
not leave the deposed king in the hands of their political enemies. On
3 April, Edward II was removed from Kenilworth and entrusted to the
custody of two subordinates of Mortimer, then later imprisoned at
Berkeley Castle in Gloucestershire where, it was generally believed, he was murdered by an agent of Isabella and Mortimer on 11 October 1327. The closest chronicler to the scene in time and distance, Adam Murimuth,
stated that it was 'popularly rumoured' that he had been suffocated.
The Lichfield chronicle, equally reflecting local opinion, stated that
he had been strangled. Most chronicles did not offer a cause of death
other than natural causes. The
popular story that the king was assassinated by having a red hot poker
thrust into his anus has no basis in accounts recorded by Edward's
contemporaries. Thomas de la Moore's account of
Edward's murder was not written until after 1352 and is uncorroborated
by other contemporary sources. Not until the relevant sections of the
longer Brut chronicle were composed by an anti - Mortimer Lancastrian
polemicist in the mid 1430s was the story widely circulated.
Ian Mortimer has put forward the argument that Edward II was not killed at Berkeley but was still alive at least until 1330. In his biography of Edward III he explores the implications of this, using evidence including the Fieschi Letter, concluding Edward II may have died in Italy around 1341. In her biography of Isabella, Alison Weir also considers the Fieschi Letter narrative – that Edward escaped imprisonment and lived the rest of his life in exile. Other historians, however, including David Carpenter have criticised Mortimer's methodology and disagree with his conclusions. Nevertheless
a public funeral was held in 1327, attended by Isabella, after which
Edward's body was said to be laid in Gloucester Cathedral. An elaborate
tomb was set up by his son which attracted pilgrims from far and wide. Following
the public announcement of the king's death, the rule of Isabella and
Mortimer did not last long. They made peace with the Scots in the Treaty of Northampton,
but this move was highly unpopular. Consequently, when Edward III came
of age in 1330, he executed Roger Mortimer on fourteen charges of
treason, most significantly the murder of Edward II (thereby removing
any public doubt about his father's survival). Edward III spared his
mother and gave her a generous allowance, but ensured that she retired
from public life for several years. She died at Hertford on 23 August
1358. Edward
II of England has been portrayed in popular culture a number of times.
The most famous fictional account of Edward II's reign is Christopher Marlowe's play Edward II (c. 1592). It depicts Edward's reign as a single narrative, and does not include Bannockburn. In 1991 English filmmaker Derek Jarman adapted the Christopher Marlowe play into a film featuring Tilda Swinton, Steven Waddington, Andrew Tiernan, Nigel Terry, and Annie Lennox.
The film specifically portrays a homosexual relationship between Edward
II and Piers Gaveston. Edward II was portrayed as an effeminate
homosexual in Braveheart. Edward II's death and sexuality are mentioned a number of times in Michael Crichton's novel Timeline. An authoritative biography of Edward II by Seymour Phillips was published in 2010. |