November 26, 2013 <Back to Index>
PAGE SPONSOR |
Ferdinand de Saussure (26 November 1857 – 22 February 1913) was a Swiss linguist whose ideas laid a foundation for many significant developments in linguistics in the 20th century. He is widely considered one of the fathers of 20th century linguistics. However, many modern linguists and philosophers of language consider his ideas outdated. Some philosophers of language believe that these critics are themselves applying outdated argumentation to portray Saussurean ideas as obscurantist or deliberately distorted. While Saussure's concepts — particularly semiotics — have received little to no attention in modern linguistic textbooks, his ideas have significantly influenced the humanities and social sciences. Ferdinand Mongin de Saussure was born in Geneva in 1857. His father was Henri Louis Frédéric de Saussure, a mineralogist, entomologist, and taxonomist. Saussure showed signs of considerable talent and intellectual ability as early as the age of fourteen. After a year of studying Latin, Greek, Sanskrit, and taking a variety of courses at the University of Geneva, he commenced graduate work at the University of Leipzig in 1876. Two years later at 21, Saussure published a book entitled Mémoire sur le système primitif des voyelles dans les langues indo - européennes (Dissertation on the Primitive Vowel System in Indo - European Languages). After this he studied for a year at Berlin, where he wrote a doctoral thesis on the genitive absolute in Sanskrit. He returned to Leipzig and was awarded his doctorate in 1880. Soon afterwards, he relocated to Paris, where he would lecture on Sanskrit, Gothic and Old High German, and occasionally other subjects. He taught at the École Pratique des Hautes Études for eleven years, during which he was named Chevalier de la Légion d'Honneur (Knight of the Legion of Honor). When offered a professorship in Geneva in 1891, he returned. Saussure lectured on Sanskrit and Indo - European at the University of Geneva for the remainder of his life. It was not until 1907 that Saussure began teaching the Course of General Linguistics, which he would offer three times, ending in the summer of 1911. He died in 1913 in Vufflens - le - Château, VD Switzerland. Saussure's most influential work, Course in General Linguistics (Cours de linguistique générale), was published posthumously in 1916 by former students Charles Bally and Albert Sechehaye on the basis of notes taken from Saussure's lectures in Geneva. The Course became one of the seminal linguistics works of the 20th century, not primarily for the content (many of the ideas had been anticipated in the works of other 20th century linguists), but rather for the innovative approach that Saussure applied in discussing linguistic phenomena. Its central notion is that language may be analyzed as a formal system of differential elements, apart from the messy dialectics of real time production and comprehension. Examples of these elements include his notion of the linguistic sign, which is composed of the signifier and the signified. Though the sign may also have a referent, Saussure took this last question to lie beyond the linguist's purview. Saussure
attempted at various times in the 1880s and 1890s to write a book on
general linguistic matters. Some of his manuscripts, including an
unfinished essay discovered in 1996, were published in Writings in General Linguistics,
though most of the material in this book had already been published in
Engler's critical edition of the Course in 1967 and 1974. While a student, Saussure published an important work in Indo - European philology that proposed the existence of ghosts in Proto - Indo - European called sonant coefficients. The Scandinavian scholar Hermann Möller suggested that these might actually be laryngeal consonants, leading to what is now known as the laryngeal theory.
It has been argued that the problem Saussure encountered, of trying to
explain how he was able to make systematic and predictive hypotheses
from known linguistic data to unknown linguistic data, stimulated his
development of structuralism.
Saussure's predictions about the existence of primate
coefficients / laryngeals and their evolution proved a resounding success
when the Hittite texts were discovered and deciphered, some 50 years later. Saussure's
ideas had a major impact on the development of linguistic theory in the
first half of the 20th century. Two currents of thought emerged
independently of each other, one in Europe, the other in America. The
results of each incorporated the basic notions of Saussurean thought in
forming the central tenets of structural linguistics. Saussure
posited that linguistic form is arbitrary, and therefore all languages
function in a similar fashion. According to Saussure, a language is
arbitrary because it is systematic in that the whole is greater than
the sum of its parts. Also, all languages have their own concepts and
sound images (or signifieds and signifiers). Therefore, Saussure
argues, languages have a relational conception of their elements: words
and their meanings are defined by comparing and contrasting their
meanings to one another. For instance, the sound images for and the
conception of a book differ from the sound images for and the
conception of a table. Languages are also arbitrary because of the
nature of their linguistic elements: they are defined in terms of their
function rather than in terms of their inherent qualities. Finally, he
posits, language has a social nature in that it provides a larger
context for analysis, determination, and realization of its structure. In Europe, the most important work in this period of influence was done by the Prague School. Most notably, Nikolay Trubetzkoy and Roman Jakobson headed the efforts of the Prague School in setting the course of phonological theory in the decades following 1940. Jakobson's universalizing structural - functional theory of phonology, based on a markedness hierarchy of distinctive features, was the first successful solution of a plane of linguistic analysis according to the Saussurean hypotheses. Elsewhere, Louis Hjelmslev and the Copenhagen School proposed new interpretations of linguistics from structuralist theoretical frameworks. In America, Saussure's ideas informed the distributionalism of Leonard Bloomfield and the post Bloomfieldian structuralism of such scholars as Eugene Nida, Bernard Bloch, George L. Trager, Rulon S. Wells III, Charles Hockett, and through Zellig Harris and the young Noam Chomsky. In addition to Chomsky's theory of Transformational grammar, other contemporary developments of structuralism included Kenneth Pike's theory of tagmemics, Sidney Lamb's theory of stratificational grammar, and Michael Silverstein's work.
By
the latter half of the 20th century, many of Saussure's ideas were
under heavy criticism. His linguistic ideas are considered important in
their time, but outdated and superseded by developments such as cognitive linguistics. In 1972, Noam Chomsky described Saussurean linguistics as an "impoverished and thoroughly inadequate conception of language," while in 1984, Marcus Mitchell declared that Saussurean linguistics were "fundamentally inadequate to process the full range of natural language [and furthermore were] held by no current researchers, to my knowledge." The field of linguistics shifted its focus from Saussurean single word analysis to analysis of whole sentences. Holland notes that up to the 1950s Saussure enjoyed some legitimacy in linguistics, but with the cognitive revolution which
began in 1957, Chomsky had "decisively refuted Saussure." She
writes: :Much of Chomsky's work is not accepted by other linguists
. . . I am not asking you to accept Chomsky's own linguistics, however.
My point is simply that Chomsky's work rendered Saussure's linguistics,
indeed much of post - Saussurean linguistics, obsolete. I am not claiming
that Chomsky is right, only that Chomsky has proven that Saussure is
wrong. Linguists who reject Chomsky claim to be going beyond Chomsky,
or they cling to phrase - structure grammars. They are not turning back
to Saussure.
Saussure is one of the founding fathers of semiotics. His concept of the sign / signifier / signified / referent forms the core of the field. The principles and methods employed by structuralism were later adapted by French Intellectuals in diverse fields, such as Roland Barthes, Jacques Lacan, and Claude Lévi - Strauss.
Such scholars took influence from Saussure's ideas in their own areas
of study (literary studies / philosophy, psychoanalysis, anthropology,
respectively). However, their analogous interpretations of Saussure's
linguistic theories led to proclamations of the end of structuralism in
those two disciplines. Saussure is the subject of The Magnetic Fields’ song "The Death of Ferdinand de Saussure" on their 1999 album 69 Love Songs. |